Background and Introduction: Vitalik Buterin, founder and chief scientist of the Ethereum project, describes his initial introduction to Bitcoin through his father in early 2013. Initially, Buterin was skeptical about Bitcoin’s potential due to its lack of intrinsic value but later became interested in its economic, technological, and political aspects.
The Shift towards Blockchain Technology: Buterin’s visit to Israel in October 2013 marked a turning point in his perspective. He encountered projects like CoveredCoins and MasterCoin, which explored applications of the blockchain beyond currency. Inspired by these projects, Buterin recognized the potential for a more generalized approach using a programming language.
The Genesis of Ethereum: Buterin proposed his idea to existing projects but faced resistance. Determined to pursue his vision, he embarked on building Ethereum, a platform that combines a Bitcoin-style blockchain with a fully featured programming language. Ethereum allows users to create autonomous agents with their own code, enabling a decentralized computing environment for various applications.
Beyond Currency: Ethereum’s capabilities extend beyond currency, enabling the creation of financial contracts, domain name registrations, and other applications. Buterin emphasizes the potential of Ethereum as “programmable money” in a way that Bitcoin aspired to be but could not achieve.
Early Involvement and Learning: Buterin’s initial involvement in the Bitcoin community was driven by earning Bitcoin through writing articles. He gained exposure to the community, learned about the technology, and experienced the value appreciation of Bitcoin. Buterin’s diverse experiences laid the foundation for his subsequent contributions to the blockchain and cryptocurrency space.
00:05:08 Blockchain Technology Evolution and Decentralization
Evolution of Blockchain Technology: Vitalik Buterin initially focused on Ethereum as a currency, but later realized its potential as a platform for decentralized applications. The flexibility of Ethereum’s programming language allowed for various use cases beyond financial contracts.
Satoshi’s Contributions and the Importance of Economics: Satoshi’s breakthrough involved integrating economics into cryptographic systems as a fundamental layer. The combination of proof-of-work and decentralized currency was revolutionary. Proof-of-work serves as a consensus algorithm and provides economic incentives for actors to participate in the network.
Decentralized Consensus Architectures: Traditional consensus architectures relied on a predefined set of servers, making them vulnerable to collusion and manipulation. Bitcoin’s free entry concept allows anyone to participate, eliminating the need for pre-existing trust and reputation. Proof-of-work ensures decentralization by assigning economic weight to computing power, disincentivizing attacks.
00:10:23 Blockchain Technology for Internet of Things
Ethereum’s Origins: Vitalik Buterin acknowledges Satoshi Nakamoto’s groundbreaking work in developing Bitcoin, including the consensus algorithm, zero-intrinsic value currency, and the paradigm shift in crypto-economics. Ethereum emerged after Bitcoin’s paradigm shift, paving the way for various applications such as Namecoin, colored coins, financial contracts, prediction markets, and more. Ethereum’s contribution lies in opening the floodgates for these applications.
IBM-Samsung Collaboration: IBM’s initial interest in cryptocurrency was sparked by an employee’s video discussing the potential of blockchain technology. The collaboration aimed to decentralize the Internet of Things (IoT) by integrating decentralized messaging protocols, file networks, and blockchain technology. Ethereum was chosen due to its adaptability to these applications. Vitalik Buterin and the Ethereum team discovered the collaboration through an announcement and subsequently reached out to IBM.
Autonomous Washer Demonstration: Samsung showcased an autonomous washer prototype powered by Ethereum’s ADAPT architecture. The washer detects low detergent levels and automatically places an order with a retailer through a smart contract. The retailer receives the order request and processes the payment through blockchain. This demonstration highlights the potential of decentralized technology in IoT applications, offering an alternative to centralized cloud-controlled systems.
Evolution of Ethereum’s Applications: Ethereum’s initial concept was a master coin with a programming language, allowing for complex scripting and financial applications. The development of a compiler enabled the creation of various blockchain-based contract applications. Financial use cases emerged first, followed by decentralized data markets, decentralized cloud computing markets, and more. Vitalik Buterin emphasizes the importance of these semi-financial use cases in shaping the future of Ethereum’s applications.
00:16:15 Decentralized File Storage: The Next Language of the Internet
Importance of Decentralized File Storage: File storage should not be dominated by a few companies, but rather be a utility accessible to all. It should be like a language, where anyone can participate and understand, not controlled by a select few.
Uncertain Future Applications of Cryptocurrency: Similar to early computers, the potential applications of cryptocurrency are initially unclear. Its future usefulness, if any, will likely emerge gradually, much like the development of programming languages.
Vitalik Buterin’s Involvement in Bitcoin Magazine: His second project in the Bitcoin community was writing articles for Bitcoin Magazine. He initially wrote for $4 per article and eventually earned $500 per month, which later increased due to Bitcoin’s rising value. The magazine served as a vehicle for him to engage with the cryptocurrency space, understand its issues, and connect with the community.
Potential Innovations in Media with Cryptocurrency: Ideas include micro-tipping, micro-paywalls, and innovative media models. However, Buterin remains skeptical of the scalability of these models in the mainstream due to human behavior and the limited examples that receive media attention.
Buterin’s Perspective on Advertising: Contrary to common sentiment, Buterin expresses appreciation for advertising. He views it as a significant economic innovation that enables businesses to reach their target audience and consumers to discover new products and services.
00:20:21 Cryptoeconomic Innovations in the Digital Age
Advertising as a Revenue Model: Vitalik Buterin argues that advertising has been transformative in making internet services free and accessible to all, especially for those who cannot afford to pay. The advertising model creates a market where people pay for products and services based on their ability to pay, which is similar to the optimal taxation policy. Ads can influence people to spend money on other things, which generates value for businesses. Buterin believes that micropayments using cryptocurrency can make ad markets more efficient and privacy-preserving.
Vitalik Buterin’s Early Business Model: In the early days of Bitcoin Weekly, Buterin experimented with a business model where he wrote articles and only released the first paragraph on a forum. The remaining part of the article was released only if people crowdfunded a certain amount of Bitcoin. This “assurance contract model” generated interest and allowed Buterin to earn a higher income per article.
Economic Experimentation with Cryptocurrency: Buterin emphasizes the ease of creating economic mechanisms using cryptocurrency. Cryptocurrency makes it easy to serve as an economic experimentation ground for various business models and payment mechanisms. Buterin suggests other innovative mechanisms, such as “badges,” where people can publicly prove their donations to a cause and gain social status. These mechanisms can facilitate the funding of public goods and services.
00:24:40 Micropayment Channels: A Scalability Solution for Bitcoin
Micropayment Channels Explained: Micropayment channels are designed to facilitate repeated payments between two parties (A and B) without requiring individual Bitcoin transactions for each payment. To initiate a micropayment channel, Party A deposits a certain amount of funds (e.g., $10) into a multi-signature (multisig) address controlled by both A and B. Instead of making multiple Bitcoin transactions, Party A signs a series of transactions that transfer the funds back and forth between A and B within the micropayment channel.
Benefits of Micropayment Channels: Scalability: By bundling multiple payments into a single settlement transaction, micropayment channels reduce the number of transactions on the Bitcoin blockchain, improving scalability. Reduced Transaction Fees: Since only one settlement transaction is recorded on the blockchain, users pay significantly lower transaction fees compared to processing individual transactions.
Use Cases for Micropayment Channels: Content Creators and Consumers: Micropayment channels can enable micro-donations to online content creators, allowing supporters to show appreciation with small payments. Online Marketplaces: Micropayment channels can facilitate small and frequent payments between buyers and sellers on online marketplaces. Subscription Services: Micropayment channels can enable recurring payments for subscription-based services, such as online streaming or content platforms.
Micropayment Channel Hubs: Micropayment channel hubs are proposed as centralized entities that manage multiple micropayment channels between various users. These hubs act as intermediaries, facilitating the creation, management, and settlement of micropayment channels. Micropayment channel hubs aim to provide a trust-free alternative to traditional centralized payment platforms like PayPal, where users retain control over their funds.
Call for Standardization: The speaker emphasizes the need for common protocols and standards for micropayment channels to ensure interoperability. The proliferation of incompatible micropayment channel solutions from different providers could hinder adoption and fragment the ecosystem. Standardization efforts are crucial to enable seamless interaction between micropayment channel providers and foster widespread adoption.
00:29:07 Practical Applications of Micropayment Channels
Unbundling Software Developers from Providers: Crypto economics enables a free entry market by separating software developers from software providers. This leads to a decentralized system, where anyone can become a micropayment channel provider.
Microtipping and Practical Use Cases: Micropayment channels have potential applications beyond microtipping. They can be used in scenarios where instant payment is necessary, such as file downloads or bandwidth allocation.
Single-Hop Mesh Networking Market: Vitalik Buterin proposes a single-hop mesh networking market to address internet connectivity issues. Individuals can download an app and serve as proxies, providing internet access to others in exchange for micropayments.
Micropayment Channels’ Advantages: Micropayment channels allow for tiny payments, making them valuable even for low-income individuals. This encourages people to participate in the market, leading to increased wireless connectivity.
Limitations of Micropayment Channels: Micropayment channels are not a generalized solution and have specific limitations. They are not suited for all types of problems and have room for improvement.
Conclusion: Vitalik Buterin highlights the potential of micropayment channels in various practical applications. While acknowledging their limitations, he emphasizes their ability to solve specific problems and provide benefits to users.
00:33:21 Emergence of Crypto-Economics and the Cryptocurrency Research Group
Crypto-Economics Overview: Vitalik Buterin introduces crypto-economics, a fusion of cryptography and economics. Cryptography provides building blocks like hash functions and public-key cryptography. Economics defines how incentives are structured in cryptographic protocols.
Cryptocurrency Research Group Inspiration: The Cryptocurrency Research Group was inspired by Buterin’s “Hard Problems in Cryptocurrency” document. The goal is to address challenges in cryptocurrency, such as scalability, consensus, identity, and reputation.
Challenges in Cryptocurrency: Proof-of-work is energy-intensive and expensive. Traditional financial systems may eventually offer similar services at a lower cost, making decentralization less competitive. Consensus mechanisms have scalability issues and may become less secure as ASIC miners improve. Every node processing every transaction is an inefficient design.
Research Efforts: The Cryptocurrency Research Group aims to solve these problems through research. They are exploring secure data input from the outside world, one ID per person systems, and reputation systems.
00:39:24 The Future of Cryptocurrency: Making it Mainstream
Raising Awareness of Cryptocurrency Problems: Vitalik Buterin introduced the Cryptocurrency and Computer Research Group (CCRG) as a platform to raise awareness about the challenges and opportunities in the cryptocurrency field. The CCRG aimed to gather a community of individuals interested in addressing these problems and exploring innovative solutions.
Encouraging Fresh Perspectives and Mainstream Adoption: Buterin emphasized the need for a fresh perspective on cryptocurrency technology to drive mainstream adoption. The CCRG sought to energize and encourage individuals to engage with cutting-edge cryptocurrency research and contribute to its development.
Lowering Barriers to Entry and Empowering Contributions: Buterin highlighted the accessibility of cryptocurrency research and development, allowing individuals to make significant contributions without extensive prior knowledge. He contrasted this with established fields like computer science and math, where years of study are typically required before making meaningful contributions.
Aspiring for Broader Engagement: Buterin expressed his desire to see more individuals involved in thinking about and contributing to cryptocurrency research and development. He emphasized the vast potential of the field and encouraged a broader community to engage with it.
Reaching Mainstream Familiarity with Cryptocurrency: One speakerposed a question about the steps needed to achieve widespread adoption of cryptocurrency, similar to the familiarity people have with the internet. Buterin’s response to this question is not included in the provided transcript.
00:41:26 Decentralized Technology: Balancing Free Entry and Trust in Practical Applications
Breadth vs. Depth: Bitcoin has reached a point where growth through breadth (increasing the number of people aware of it) is limited. In order for cryptocurrency to succeed, it needs to move from breadth to depth, which means increasing the level of involvement of each individual person.
Practical Applications: Practical applications are essential for the long-term success of cryptocurrency, as they provide fundamental benefits that are stable and worthwhile. The financial system in the US is not a fundamental advantage for Bitcoin, as it may be a transient issue that will eventually fix itself or be displaced by other technologies.
Censorship Resistance: Silk Road demonstrated the fundamental advantage of cryptocurrency as censorship-resistant, as it allows for transactions that would otherwise be shut down.
Decentralized Technology and Trust: There is a fundamental trade-off between free entry and trust in many industries. The more free entry is added, the more friction and trust issues arise.
File Storage and Trust Problems: File storage is an example of an industry where trust problems arise due to high free entry. Ensuring quality of service, incentivizing continued file storage, and trusting people to hold data are significant challenges.
Centralized vs. Decentralized Markets: Centralized markets solve trust problems by giving up free entry, leading to monopoly problems. Decentralized markets, enabled by cryptography and crypto-economics, aim to maintain high free entry while ensuring a higher degree of trust.
Erasure Coding: Erasure coding is a protocol that allows for secure and reliable file storage in a decentralized manner. It involves splitting a file into multiple chunks, any of which can be used to reconstruct the original file.
00:49:21 Cryptocurrency: Possibilities and Pitfalls
Decentralization and Incentivization: Vitalik Buterin argues that decentralization in cryptocurrency systems, where data is split across multiple computers, ensures reliability and minimizes the risk of data loss. He emphasizes the importance of incentivization through economic mechanisms like security deposits and automated penalties to maintain trust and prevent malicious behavior.
Cryptocurrency’s Potential and Challenges: Buterin believes cryptocurrency could potentially replace gold as the world’s reserve currency due to its predictable supply and the environmental benefits of proof of work compared to gold mining. He acknowledges the possibility of cryptocurrency becoming a niche tool for specific applications like interbank clearing and international trade.
Spectrum of Possibilities: Buterin envisions a range of outcomes for cryptocurrency, from limited use cases to widespread adoption across industries and even the potential for replacing governments with decentralized autonomous organizations (DAOs).
Challenges and Network Effects: The success of cryptocurrency relies on network effects, where increasing adoption leads to greater benefits. However, it is difficult to predict where on the spectrum of possibilities cryptocurrency will fall due to the inherent uncertainty of startups.
Comparison to Venture Capital: Buterin compares cryptocurrency’s trajectory to startups, where there is a high probability of failure but also the potential for exceptional success.
Drake Equation Analogy: Buterin draws a parallel between cryptocurrency’s potential and the Drake equation, which attempts to estimate the probability of intelligent extraterrestrial life. He highlights the complex interplay of factors that determine cryptocurrency’s success.
Interplay of Ideas: Buterin emphasizes the interdependency of various concepts in cryptocurrency, such as free entry markets, personal freedom, economic ideas, and the use of public-key cryptography for secure payments.
Uncertainties and Multiplicative Effects: The success of cryptocurrency hinges on the interplay of these ideas, and it is challenging to predict which directions will thrive. In some cases, success is multiplicative, while in others, it is additive, meaning that the success of any one direction can positively impact the overall outcome.
00:58:29 Vitalik Buterin Explores Future of Blockchain Technology
Blockchain Ecosystems: Buterin highlights the potential for exponential growth in the cryptocurrency market. He believes that multiple successful blockchain ecosystems could coexist and scale significantly.
Government as DAO: Buterin speculates on a scenario where governments could be run as decentralized autonomous organizations (DAOs). He envisions either a utopian outcome or a dystopian scenario where the DAO turns against humanity.
DAO’s Limited Perspective: Buterin emphasizes the need for DAOs to consider long-term sustainability and the involvement of humans in their maintenance. He criticizes the tendency to forget the practical realities of maintaining a blockchain system.
Improving Blockchain Technology: Buterin emphasizes the importance of improving blockchain technology, particularly in reducing the cost of consensus mechanisms. He believes that these improvements are crucial for the viability and long-term success of blockchain technology.
Bitcoin as a Starting Point: Buterin acknowledges that Bitcoin was a revolutionary first implementation of blockchain technology. He advocates for a fresh perspective and critical examination of Bitcoin’s design to identify areas for improvement.
Protocol TV Promotion: The speaker encourages viewers to follow their Twitter account for updates on new videos and content related to blockchain technology.
Abstract
“Deciphering Vitalik Buterin’s Vision: The Evolution, Impact, and Future of Ethereum and Cryptocurrency”
In this comprehensive exploration, we delve into the profound impact of Vitalik Buterin’s innovations in blockchain and cryptocurrency, particularly Ethereum, and the evolving landscape of decentralized technologies. From Ethereum’s inception as a fusion of Bitcoin’s blockchain with advanced programming capabilities to its current role in redefining financial and technological paradigms, this article examines the pivotal developments and challenges in the field. We also forecast the potential trajectories of cryptocurrency, weighing both optimistic and pessimistic scenarios, to offer a nuanced perspective on its future influence on global finance, governance, and technology.
Ethereum’s Genesis and Buterin’s Vision:
Vitalik Buterin’s journey into blockchain technology began with an encounter with Bitcoin in early 2013, initially met with skepticism. However, encouragement from his father and further exploration led him to appreciate Bitcoin’s potential in various aspects, not just its intrinsic value. A pivotal moment came during Buterin’s visit to Israel in October 2013, where he discovered projects like CoveredCoins and MasterCoin, revealing the blockchain’s applications beyond just currency. Inspired by these, Buterin envisioned Ethereum as a more generalized blockchain platform, incorporating a programming language to broaden its capabilities.
Blockchain Technology’s Evolution:
Ethereum represents a significant evolution in blockchain technology, moving beyond its original focus on currency. This shift was influenced by Satoshi Nakamoto’s groundbreaking integration of economics into cryptographic systems. Vitalik Buterin expanded upon this by recognizing the potential for a more generalized blockchain platform. This led to the development of applications like Namecoin, financial contracts, and prediction markets. Additionally, Buterin’s experience with Bitcoin Magazine enriched his understanding of the cryptocurrency space, connecting him with the community and informing him of the industry’s challenges and opportunities.
Decentralization and Consensus:
Ethereum and Bitcoin embody the ethos of decentralization through their consensus architectures, which differ from traditional systems that relied on pre-selected servers. These platforms use a combination of free entry and economic incentives, based on computing power, to maintain both security and decentralization. Particularly, the proof-of-work mechanism promotes legitimate behavior while discouraging malicious activities.
Buterin’s Contributions and Ethereum’s Applications:
Buterin’s contributions to Ethereum’s development focused on paving the way for innovation rather than creating specific applications. His vision enabled a diverse range of applications, including Namecoin and financial contracts. Buterin also acknowledges the transformative role of advertising in making internet services accessible, suggesting that cryptocurrency could enhance the efficiency and privacy of ad markets through micropayments.
IBM-Samsung Collaboration and Ethereum’s Expanding Horizons:
The collaboration between IBM and Samsung in exploring decentralized Internet of Things (IoT) applications marked a significant expansion of Ethereum’s utility. This partnership, influenced by Buterin’s insights, furthered the development of decentralized messaging protocols, file networks, and blockchain integration. Samsung’s demonstration of an autonomous washer powered by Ethereum’s ADAPT architecture highlighted the potential of decentralized technology in IoT applications.
Future Outlook on Cryptocurrency by Buterin:
Buterin envisions a future where cryptocurrency’s potential parallels the unforeseen applications of early computers. His experience with Bitcoin Magazine and perspectives on advertising, micro-tipping, and paywalls shed light on the scalability of cryptocurrency and its potential role in mainstream media. He imagines a future where services like file storage and internet connectivity are delivered in new, monetized ways, emphasizing the unpredictable future applications of cryptocurrency.
Cryptocurrency’s Emerging Role and Economic Models:
Cryptocurrency has facilitated the creation of new economic mechanisms, serving as a platform for innovative approaches like micropayment channels. These channels offer scalability solutions and reduce transaction costs for specific use cases. Buterin envisions a free-entry market where the roles of software developers and providers are distinct, promoting a more democratized tech landscape. His early experimentation with Bitcoin Weekly through an “assurance contract model” further illustrates this vision.
Challenges and Research in Cryptocurrency:
The cryptocurrency field faces significant challenges, including consensus efficiency, centralization risks, and scalability. Buterin’s vision, as seen in the Cryptocurrency Research Group (CRRG), aims to address these issues, making decentralized technology more competitive in the mainstream. He focuses on practical solutions that leverage cryptocurrency’s unique advantages, like censorship resistance.
Decentralization in Practice and Possible Scenarios:
Decentralization in cryptocurrency takes various forms, from the distribution of data across multiple computers to economic incentives ensuring honesty among service providers. The potential outcomes for cryptocurrency are diverse, ranging from replacing traditional financial systems to remaining a niche tool. Buterin emphasizes the need for real-world problem-solving, community commitment, and regulatory support for cryptocurrency’s success.
Vitalik Buterin’s contributions to Ethereum and the broader cryptocurrency landscape are monumental, catalyzing significant advancements in blockchain technology and decentralized systems. His vision for cryptocurrency extends beyond its current applications, aiming for mainstream adoption through practical, real-world solutions. This journey, however, is contingent on overcoming technological, economic, and regulatory challenges. As the field evolves, Buterin’s insights and Ethereum’s trajectory will continue to shape the future of finance, governance, and technological innovation.
Incorporated Additional Insights:
Buterin’s concept of crypto-economics fosters a market where software developers are separate from providers, leading to decentralized systems where anyone can become a micropayment channel provider. Micropayment channels have broader applications, such as in scenarios requiring instant payment for services like file downloads or bandwidth allocation.
Buterin proposes a single-hop mesh networking market to address internet connectivity, where individuals can provide internet access to others via an app, in exchange for micropayments. He recognizes the energy-intensive nature of proof-of-work and the scalability challenges in consensus mechanisms. Buterin emphasizes the importance of raising awareness about cryptocurrency, empowering developers, and encouraging new perspectives for mainstream adoption.
He believes that practical applications are crucial for cryptocurrency’s long-term success, highlighting its fundamental advantage as a censorship-resistant tool. Trust issues in industries with high free entry, such as file storage, pose significant challenges. Decentralized markets, supported by cryptography and crypto-economics, aim to maintain trust while allowing high free entry.
Erasure coding is noted as a protocol for secure and reliable file storage in a decentralized manner, involving splitting files into chunks for reconstruction. Buterin argues for incentivization in decentralized systems through economic mechanisms to maintain trust and prevent malicious behavior.
He envisions cryptocurrency potentially replacing gold as a reserve currency and speculates on a wide range of outcomes for cryptocurrency, from limited use cases to widespread adoption. The trajectory of cryptocurrency is compared to startups, with inherent uncertainties and potential for exceptional success. Buterin draws parallels between cryptocurrency’s potential and the Drake equation, emphasizing the interplay of various concepts like free entry markets, personal freedom, and secure payments in determining its success.
The possibility of multiple successful blockchain ecosystems coexisting and scaling significantly is highlighted. Buterin speculates on governments running as decentralized autonomous organizations (DAOs) and criticizes the tendency to overlook practical realities in maintaining blockchain systems. He advocates for improvements in blockchain technology, particularly in reducing consensus mechanism costs, and encourages a fresh perspective on Bitcoin’s design. Buterin’s commitment to advancing blockchain technology and decentralized systems is evident throughout his work and vision.
Vitalik Buterin's work on Ethereum and his commitment to societal good through philanthropic actions. Introduction of Proof-of-Stake (PoS) consensus and Sharding as key features in Ethereum 2.0 for enhanced security, energy efficiency, and equitable rewards distribution....
Ethereum's evolution has been marked by challenges like scalability and network complexity, while DeFi and yield farming raise concerns about sustainability. Vitalik Buterin emphasizes the importance of balancing coin supply stability with security, while Ethereum 2.0 aims to address these issues and expand the platform's applications....
Vitalik Buterin sees Bitcoin and Ethereum as specializing in different areas, with Bitcoin being an asset and store of value and Ethereum valuing the network over the asset. Cryptocurrencies offer diverse use cases beyond payments and subscriptions, leading to fierce competition for global liquidity....
Ethereum has undergone significant technological advancements, community growth, and challenges in its five-year journey, transforming from a mere concept to a multifaceted platform influencing various sectors. Despite its progress, Ethereum faces challenges in defining its scope, addressing concerns about speculation and inequality, and mitigating the negative consequences of cryptocurrency....
Vitalik Buterin emphasizes the importance of practicality, security, and community effort in driving Ethereum's adoption and sees Ethereum as a potential solution to the internet's identity problem. He also acknowledges the importance of non-Ethereum projects that align with blockchain principles....
Blockchain technology offers innovative solutions for governance, public goods funding, and education, while also challenging traditional concepts of immutability and security. Despite its potential, the complexity and fragmentation within the crypto space call for improved accessibility of information and a focus on decentralization....
Vitalik Buterin discussed challenges in cryptocurrency, emphasizing the need to differentiate legitimate projects from dubious ones, and highlighted the importance of thoughtful approaches to decentralized data storage and Ethereum's leadership. He also expressed skepticism about the feasibility of pairing Bitcoin with unproven Layer 2 concepts and advocated for a broader...