Vitalik Buterin (Ethereum Co-founder) – Ethereum in the Next Decade | EDCON2023 (Jun 2023)
Chapters
00:00:02 Ethereum: Beyond Theory, Towards Practical Decentralization
Ethereum’s Journey: Over the past decade, Ethereum focused on solving theoretical problems, such as creating a blockchain with a general-purpose programming language. The scalability problem has been a significant challenge, leading to the exploration of various solutions like lightning networks, state channels, plasma, roll-ups, and sharding.
Current Status and Challenges: Despite progress, the crypto space remains relatively small, and many people have yet to find practical uses for Ethereum beyond trading digital assets. However, there are regions where people rely on cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin and Ethereum for payments, savings, and even basic DAOs due to hyper-inflation, lack of access to global financial systems, or political issues.
Centralized Exchanges: Many people use centralized exchanges for convenience and low transaction fees, despite the risk of failure and the lack of true decentralization.
Decentralization as a Key Goal: True decentralization is essential to fulfill the promises of crypto and protect users from systemic risks and unexpected events.
Scalability and Usability: The current decentralized technology is not sufficient, hindering broader adoption and limiting the number of use cases.
Ongoing Efforts and Hopes: Developers are working to improve the scalability and usability of decentralized technology to enable wider adoption and fulfillment of Ethereum’s potential.
00:07:43 Key Challenges in Blockchain Technology: Privacy, Consensus, Scalability, and User Account
Privacy: Vitalik emphasizes the importance of privacy in the cryptocurrency space.
Consensus Safety: Ensuring blockchain consensus doesn’t break or become centralized is a crucial concern. Implementing improvements like single slot finality and making it easier to be a validator are ongoing challenges.
Smart Contract Safety: Vitalik acknowledges the progress made in smart contract safety, but user account safety is becoming more prominent. The availability of reusable and time-tested codebases has reduced the need for entirely new smart contracts.
User Account Safety: The growing adoption of crypto for storing assets necessitates robust user account safety. Vitalik highlights the importance of audits and rebranding to maintain trust in crypto applications.
Examples of Trusted Applications: Uniswap, Gnosis Safe, ERC-20 contracts, and wrapped ETH are examples of applications that have stood the test of time.
User Account Safety: Mass adoption of crypto requires reliable user account safety. Losing a piece of paper with a seed phrase or having a phone hacked can lead to stolen funds. Basic user account safety is essential, especially for users who depend on crypto for their livelihood. Hardware wallets are not a perfect solution and have their own security risks.
Basic Use Cases: Holding coins and making payments are fundamental crypto use cases. Complex smart contract interactions may not be as widespread as basic transactions. Ensuring user account safety is crucial for basic use cases to function effectively.
Fees and Scalability: Using popular public blockchains like Ethereum or Bitcoin comes with high fees and scalability challenges. Demand for Ethereum has surged over the past decade, leading to increased transaction costs.
00:13:26 Ethereum Scalability: Progress and Challenges
Rollup-Centric Roadmap: Vitalik Buterin proposed a rollup-centric roadmap for Ethereum scaling three years ago. Rollups are Layer 2 scaling solutions that offer high scalability and security. Data and computation occur off-chain, while only a small amount of data is stored on the blockchain.
Stages of Rollup Development: Vitalik Buterin developed a classification system for rollup maturity. Stage zero is the training stage, while stages one and two involve removing training wheels and decentralizing the rollup. Polygon is currently the only stage one rollup on mainnet, with others like Optimism, Arbitrom, Scroll, Tyco, ZK-Sync, and Linea close behind.
Progress in Scalability: Since the Merge, Ethereum has focused on scalability. Proof of stake, once a subject of ridicule, is now fully implemented. Rollups have made significant progress, with several projects nearing full decentralization.
Conclusion: Ethereum is actively addressing scalability challenges. Rollups have emerged as a promising scaling solution, offering high scalability and security. Several rollup projects are approaching full decentralization, indicating substantial progress in Ethereum’s scalability efforts.
00:16:41 Ethereum Roll-ups and User Experience Challenges
EIP-4844 and Roll-up Scaling: EIP-4844 aims to increase Ethereum’s on-chain space for roll-ups, leading to higher scalability. With EIP-4844 and future versions of Dank Sharding, Ethereum’s transaction capacity is expected to grow significantly, from 16 TPS to between 20,000 and 100,000 TPS.
User Experience Challenges with Multiple Roll-ups: Different roll-ups have emerged, creating a fragmented user experience. Challenges arise when users need to interact with multiple roll-ups, each with its own address system and limitations. Applications may be restricted to specific roll-ups, causing inconvenience for users who want to use services across different platforms.
ENS Moving to Layer 2s: ENS currently exists only on Ethereum mainnet, making it expensive to register new names. The CCIP proposal allows ENS to be integrated into various Layer 2 systems. This enables users to register and use ENS names on different Layer 2s, improving accessibility and cost-effectiveness.
Practical User Experience Improvements Needed: Layer 2 user experience needs to be as seamless and intuitive as Layer 1. Wallets must be upgraded to support multiple Layer 2s without compromising security and decentralization.
Challenges in Wallet Security: Wallet security remains a significant concern in the cryptocurrency ecosystem. Vitalik Buterin highlights an article from 2013 emphasizing the importance of wallet security and the risks associated with weak practices.
What Happened to Vitalik Buterin’s Bitcoin Wallet: Vitalik Buterin lost 2.07 bitcoins due to a malicious Java program that compromised his Bitcoin wallet. Others have lost much more, with one person losing 25,000 BTC.
Multisig Wallets: Multisig wallets use multiple keys to authorize transactions, increasing security. The Ethereum Foundation uses a multisig wallet with seven keys, requiring four approvals for transactions. Multisig wallets can be more complex and less efficient, but they are worth the cost for large sums of money.
Social Recovery: Social recovery wallets allow users to recover their wallets if they lose their keys, requiring multiple approvals from guardians. Social recovery is good for hot wallets, while multisig is better for cold wallets.
Challenges with Social Recovery and Multisig: User experience challenges include managing multiple accounts across different L2s and recovering counterfactual accounts. Privacy concerns arise, as guardians may be able to see the transactions and assets of the wallet holder.
Addressing Privacy Concerns: Privacy-preserving social recovery systems are possible but require advanced mathematics.
Cash Payments: Cash payments have been a fundamental part of human civilization for thousands of years.
00:29:54 Digitalization and the Erosion of Privacy: A Crypto Perspective
Vitalik’s View on Privacy: Vitalik Buterin believes that privacy is a human right and it is important in payments. He believes that digitization is eroding privacy in various spheres. He points out a quote from the World Economic Forum that reflects a concerning mentality regarding privacy.
Importance of Privacy in Digitized Systems: Vitalik emphasizes that digitized systems inherently lack privacy. To achieve privacy in digital systems, cryptography and deliberate efforts are required. He criticizes central bank digital currency proposals for not providing real privacy.
Loss of Privacy in Various Forms: Vitalik observes that many apps are being created without considering privacy. He highlights the rapid decline of various forms of privacy in the digital era.
Crypto Space as a Potential Alternative: Vitalik sees the crypto space as one of the few spaces that can offer a realistic alternative for privacy.
Challenge of Digital Privacy at High Value Transactions: While digital privacy offers convenience, it also poses challenges. Vitalik points out that moving large sums of money digitally can be problematic due to the ease of transfer.
00:32:56 Privacy for the Weak and Transparency for the Powerful: Zero-Knowledge Proofs and Financial
Privacy and Transparency in the Digital Age: Julian Assange’s vision of privacy for the weak and transparency for the powerful as a guiding principle. The potential of zero-knowledge proofs to strike a balance between privacy and traceability.
Proof-of-Innocence Protocol: Concept of a mixer like TornadoCash where users deposit and withdraw coins. Proving that coins are not associated with scams, hacks, or illicit activities without revealing the link between input and output coins.
Automated Zero-Knowledge Proofs: Default privacy for all participants in privacy systems. Boycotting coins associated with suspicious events reduces the pool of mixable coins for illicit actors.
Development Efforts: Ongoing work by various development teams, including Chainway and Amin Soleimani, to enhance privacy through zero-knowledge proofs.
Educational Significance: Zero-knowledge proofs offer a unique combination of privacy and security guarantees. The ability to prove innocence without revealing all personal information.
Other Privacy Considerations: Doxing concerns when using ENS names for receiving assets. Public links created between interacting parties on the blockchain.
00:38:20 Pathways and Progress in Privacy, Scalability, and Security
ZK-SNARKs and Scalability: ZK-SNARKs (Zero-Knowledge Succinct Non-Interactive Arguments of Knowledge) are crucial for achieving scalability in crypto. ZK-rollups, such as Kakarot, Linnea, zk-sync, and Polygon, rely on ZK-SNARKs to process transactions off-chain and improve scalability on the main chain.
Privacy: Stealth addresses allow users to receive funds without creating a public link between the recipient and the address, enhancing privacy. This technology is particularly beneficial for charities and political activist groups that want to collect funds while protecting the identities of their donors.
Social Recovery and Privacy: ZK Social Recovery enables users to recover their lost keys without compromising the privacy of their assets. It separates the concept of an address holding assets from the concept of a key store, allowing key recovery without revealing links between different assets.
ZKE VMs and ZK-SNARKs: ZKE Virtual Machines (ZKE VMs) are powerful tools that allow developers to create privacy-preserving applications. Running ZK-AVMs on mainnet has surpassed expectations, with ZK-SNARKs proving to be a transformative technology in the crypto space.
Long-Term Vision: The problems of privacy, scalability, and security remain the same as in 2017, but solutions have advanced from theory to practice. ZK-SNARKs are revolutionizing the field, with their capabilities exceeding expectations and opening up new possibilities for privacy and scalability. The next 10 years will witness significant progress in these areas, shaping the future of crypto and blockchain technology.
00:43:48 Future of Ethereum: User-Friendly Decentralized Technology
Ethereum’s Potential: Vitalik Buterin believes Ethereum has the potential to offer significant improvements over centralized systems in terms of cost, privacy, security, and user experience. By utilizing technological advancements, Ethereum can reduce transaction fees, enhance privacy for identity systems and reputations, and provide safer account systems.
Decentralized Technology’s Superiority: Buterin believes decentralized technology can surpass centralized systems in terms of user experience and functionality. Once fully decentralized technology achieves this, users will be able to utilize blockchains without relying on centralized intermediaries.
Challenges and Collaboration: The realization of Ethereum’s full potential requires substantial technical work and collaboration among various stakeholders. Buterin emphasizes the need for wallet builders, ENS, applications, and other ecosystem participants to work together to achieve standardization and interoperability.
Standardization and Interoperability: Buterin highlights the importance of standardization and interoperability to ensure a seamless user experience across different wallets, applications, and protocols. He points out the need for applications to support smart contract wallets, ERC-1271, and other standards to ensure compatibility with various Ethereum wallets.
Challenges in Achieving Standardization: Buterin acknowledges the difficulty of standardizing across the entire Ethereum ecosystem, noting that it is easier to create an alpha version than to achieve widespread adoption of standards. He emphasizes the need for coordination and collaboration among ecosystem participants to ensure that protocols are upgraded in a unified manner.
Ethereum’s Core Values: Buterin reiterates Ethereum’s core values of decentralization, openness, censorship resistance, permissionlessness, and borderlessness. He envisions an Ethereum ecosystem where these values are preserved, and collaboration leads to the creation of a beautiful Ethereum stack that solves key problems for users in the future.
Abstract
Analyzing Ethereum’s Evolution and Future: From Theoretical Foundations to Practical Solutions
Abstract
Ethereum’s journey began with a focus on solving theoretical blockchain problems, primarily aiming to create a blockchain with a general-purpose programming language for smart contracts and applications. Scalability surfaced as a persistent challenge, spurring the exploration of various solutions like the lightning network, state channels, plasma, roll-ups, and sharding. Despite these advancements, cryptocurrency adoption remained limited, with many people relying on traditional financial and identity systems. However, in regions plagued by hyperinflation, weak financial systems, or political instability, Ethereum emerged as a lifeline for savings and payments.
Ethereum’s Past and Present: Theoretical Foundations and Real-World Challenges
Vitalik Buterin envisions the next decade of Ethereum as a period to bridge the gap between theory and practice. The focus is on technological advancements that enable true decentralization, fostering a user-friendly, scalable, and secure ecosystem. This vision aims to empower individuals with control over their assets and data, contributing to a more inclusive and equitable financial system.
The Vulnerabilities of Centralized Exchanges
Centralized exchanges, while offering convenience, low fees, instant transactions, and protection against user errors, have been criticized for their susceptibility to failure, fraud, and censorship. These vulnerabilities pose significant risks to the resilience and promises of decentralized crypto systems.
Emphasizing the Need for True Decentralization
The criticality of true decentralization in fostering a robust crypto ecosystem cannot be overstated. Current decentralized technologies fall short in some aspects, impeding widespread adoption. This gap underscores the necessity for technological advancements that align with the ethos of decentralization.
Ethereum’s Future: Bridging Theory and Practice
Vitalik Buterin’s vision for the next decade of Ethereum centers around bridging the gap between theoretical foundations and practical applications. Technological advancements are being pursued to facilitate true decentralization, leading to a user-friendly, scalable, and secure ecosystem. The focus is on empowering individuals with control over their assets and data, fostering a more inclusive and equitable financial system.
Key challenges in 2017 were identified as privacy, consensus safety, smart contract safety, and scalability. Ethereum’s current endeavors include the transition to Proof-of-Stake, upgrading consensus mechanisms, and enhancing user account safety. Additionally, safeguarding assets stored in crypto has become a priority, underscoring the significance of user account safety and the availability of time-tested and audited codebases.
Achievements and Ongoing Efforts
Ethereum’s transition from Proof-of-Work to Proof-of-Stake marked a significant milestone. However, challenges persist, such as MEV-related issues and consensus security. Ensuring user account safety, particularly for asset storage, remains a pressing concern.
The Role of Rollups in Ethereum’s Scalability
Vitalik Buterin proposed a rollup-centric roadmap three years ago, which continues to be a cornerstone of Ethereum’s scalability strategy. Rollups, as Layer 2 solutions, leverage blockchain security while minimizing data storage on the blockchain. They offer scalability comparable to or higher than Ethereum with equivalent security levels. Rollups’ progression towards scalable solutions is reflected in their maturity stages, ranging from a training stage to fully decentralized and trustless.
User Experience and Wallet Security: Vital Components
Buterin emphasizes the need to enhance the user experience of Layer 2s, making them as user-friendly as Layer 1. Wallet security, including multi-signature and social recovery methods, is highlighted as crucial for preventing theft and loss of digital assets. The introduction of ERC4337 provides increased flexibility in managing keys and facilitating transaction limits.
Privacy in the Digital Age: A Core Concern
Vitalik Buterin emphasizes the importance of privacy in payments, inherent in cash transactions throughout history. The digitization of financial systems often compromises privacy, necessitating cryptography and conscious efforts to preserve it. He advocates for an ideal world where privacy is ensured for small transactions, while transparency prevails for larger ones. Zero-knowledge proofs emerge as a powerful technology, enabling sophisticated combinations of privacy and transparency.
Ethereum’s Future Vision: Cost, Privacy, Security, and User Experience
Buterin envisions Ethereum achieving significant improvements in cost, privacy, security, and user experience, potentially surpassing centralized systems. Collaboration and standardization among wallet builders, applications, and other ecosystem participants are key to realizing these benefits. Preserving Ethereum’s core values of decentralization, openness, and censorship resistance is paramount. The goal is to create a seamless user experience across different layers and wallets, solving scalability, privacy, and security challenges for all users.
Progress and Challenges in Ethereum Scaling
Rollup-Centric Roadmap:
– Vitalik Buterin proposed a rollup-centric roadmap for Ethereum scaling three years ago.
– Rollups, as Layer 2 scaling solutions, offer high scalability and security.
– Data and computation occur off-chain, while only a small amount of data is stored on the blockchain.
Stages of Rollup Development:
– Buterin developed a classification system for rollup maturity.
– Stage zero is the training stage, while stages one and two involve removing training wheels and decentralizing the rollup.
– Polygon is currently the only stage one rollup on mainnet, with others like Optimism, Arbitrom, Scroll, Tyco, ZK-Sync, and Linea close behind.
Progress in Scalability:
– Since the Merge, Ethereum has focused on scalability.
– Proof of stake, once a subject of ridicule, is now fully implemented.
– Rollups have made significant progress, with several projects nearing full decentralization.
EIP-4844 and Roll-up Scaling:
– EIP-4844 aims to increase Ethereum’s on-chain space for roll-ups, leading to higher scalability.
– With EIP-4844 and future versions of Dank Sharding, Ethereum’s transaction capacity is expected to grow significantly, from 16 TPS to between 20,000 and 100,000 TPS.
User Experience Challenges with Multiple Roll-ups:
– Different roll-ups have emerged, creating a fragmented user experience.
– Challenges arise when users need to interact with multiple roll-ups, each with its own address system and limitations.
– Applications may be restricted to specific roll-ups, causing inconvenience for users who want to use services across different platforms.
Multisig Wallets, Social Recovery, and Privacy Challenges:
Multisig Wallets:
– Multisig wallets use multiple keys to authorize transactions, increasing security.
– The Ethereum Foundation uses a multisig wallet with seven keys, requiring four approvals for transactions.
– Multisig wallets can be more complex and less efficient, but they are worth the cost for large sums of money.
Conclusion
Ethereum’s evolution from theoretical foundations to a practical, scalable, and user-centric platform showcases the dynamic nature of the cryptocurrency ecosystem. The ongoing efforts to address challenges in scalability, security, privacy, and user experience reflect the commitment to realizing Ethereum’s full potential. As the platform continues to advance, the harmony between technological progress and user-centric solutions will play a pivotal role in shaping the future of decentralized finance and the broader cryptocurrency landscape.
Ethereum's vision includes social recovery wallets for enhanced security, Layer 2 solutions like rollups for scalability, and empowering users and minimizing trust through technological advancements....
Ethereum roadmap focuses on scalability, security, and decentralization, aiming to make transactions affordable for everyday users. Cryptocurrencies can potentially address global challenges like financial inclusion and climate change, but a truly decentralized, neutral, and scalable blockchain ecosystem is crucial....
Vitalik Buterin's work on Ethereum and his commitment to societal good through philanthropic actions. Introduction of Proof-of-Stake (PoS) consensus and Sharding as key features in Ethereum 2.0 for enhanced security, energy efficiency, and equitable rewards distribution....
Ethereum's scalability challenges are addressed through roll-ups, Layer 2 solutions, and the phased development of Ethereum 2.0. Vitalik Buterin highlights the potential of roll-ups to increase transaction throughput significantly and proposes integrating them into wallets and applications for a better user experience....
Ethereum's evolution has been marked by challenges like scalability and network complexity, while DeFi and yield farming raise concerns about sustainability. Vitalik Buterin emphasizes the importance of balancing coin supply stability with security, while Ethereum 2.0 aims to address these issues and expand the platform's applications....
Vitalik Buterin, the co-founder of Ethereum, discusses the future of technology, including the transition to proof-of-stake, the potential of zk-rollups, and the challenges associated with radical medical technologies. He also shares his thoughts on Latin America, biotechnology, and personal growth....
Ethereum 2.0, with proof-of-stake and sharding, aims to improve scalability, energy efficiency, and democratic participation, while preserving Ethereum's core values of permissionlessness, decentralization, and value-based governance. Rollups and EIP-1559 further enhance scalability and security, positioning Ethereum as a resilient and versatile platform for a wide range of applications....