Steven Chu (Stanford Professor) – Remarks at The Electrochemical Society (Nov 2017)
Chapters
00:00:05 Future Climate Risks and the Changing Energy Landscape
Risks of Climate Change: Average global temperature has risen by about one degree centigrade since 1975. Glaciers are melting, and sea levels are rising at an accelerating rate. Antarctica, which is supposed to accumulate ice, is losing mass, especially in Western Antarctica. The UN goal of keeping sea level rise to six to nine meters may not be achievable in thousands of years, but it may happen in 100 to 200 years due to the acceleration. The climate is more sensitive to temperature changes than previously thought.
Changing Landscape of Energy: Technology in the oil and gas industry is improving, leading to better extraction rates and more accessible high-value carbon. The transition to solutions that are economically competitive and better than oil and natural gas is necessary. Agriculture and land use, including methane emissions from cows and overfertilization, contribute significantly to greenhouse gases, comparable to the electricity sector.
Role of Electrochemistry: Renewable energy sources, such as wind and solar, are becoming increasingly cost-competitive with traditional energy sources like natural gas. Offshore wind prices are also declining. Electrochemistry plays a crucial role in energy storage and conversion, enabling the integration of renewable energy sources into the grid. New electrochemical technologies, such as solid-state batteries, have the potential to further improve energy storage and efficiency.
00:13:02 The Future of Energy Storage and Transmission
Cost of Renewable Energy: Offshore wind prices are becoming competitive with nuclear power, although subsidized. Onshore wind and solar power can reach unsubsidized costs of around 3 cents per kilowatt hour in favorable locations. The expectation is that within a decade, renewable energy costs could decline to 2 cents per kilowatt hour. Shell, an oil and gas company, estimates electricity prices could reach 1.5 cents per kilowatt hour in certain regions by 2040.
Challenges of High Renewable Energy Penetration: As the percentage of electricity generated from renewables increases, the need for storage, backup systems, and improved transmission lines becomes more critical. The cost of renewables may be low, but the overall system cost increases due to the complexity of managing a highly variable power grid.
Machine Learning in Energy Distribution: Machine learning can play a significant role in managing the complex distribution system of a high renewable energy grid. Machines can automate the distribution and management of two-way flows, optimize energy use and weather predictions, and improve overall grid stability.
Energy Storage: Pumped hydro storage is a cost-effective and efficient method of energy storage. In Chile, a large solar farm is being constructed alongside a 300-megawatt pumped hydro storage facility to store excess solar energy. The round-trip efficiency of pumped hydro storage is around 85%, making it a viable option for large-scale energy storage.
Battery Technology Advancements: Battery costs have plummeted since the introduction of electric vehicles in the mid-2000s. EV battery manufacturing costs have decreased from $1,200-$1,500 to $250-$300 per kilowatt hour. The Tesla Gigafactory aims to achieve costs of $125 per kilowatt hour at full production. Progress in battery technology, including volume energy density, has exceeded expert projections.
Challenges in Battery Development: Current battery designs face stability issues due to large volume changes during charging and discharging. Advanced battery designs, such as lithium-silicon and lithium-sulfur batteries, have promising energy density but require further research and development.
Battery Energy Density Comparison: Lead-acid batteries have low energy density, while lithium-ion batteries offer higher energy per unit weight and volume. Lithium metal batteries have the potential for even higher energy density but face stability challenges.
00:22:05 Lithium-Ion Battery Innovation for Mobile Devices
Improved Energy Density: Lithium-ion battery manufacturers are delivering samples with energy density of 750 watt-hours per liter, a significant improvement from the initial 250 watt-hours per liter. Cell phone manufacturers prioritize energy density per unit volume to reduce device thickness.
Modest Weight-Based Energy Improvement: Energy density per unit weight has not seen as much improvement, remaining around 200 watt-hours per kilogram. Cell phones are less concerned with weight compared to volume.
Optimism for Future Developments: Experts believe that 400 watt-hours per kilogram and 800 watt-hours per liter are achievable within the next 5 to 10 years.
Promising Research on Silicon Anodes: Yi Shui, a professor and expert in electrochemistry, is conducting research on silicon anodes. Silicon anodes have a higher lithium storage capacity than carbon anodes, allowing for improved energy density. Silicon anodes can store over 4 lithium ions per silicon atom, compared to 6 or 7 carbons required for carbon anodes.
00:24:37 Innovative Battery Technologies and Challenges
Theoretical Efficiency of Battery Materials: Silicon has a much higher theoretical efficiency than metal as a battery material. Metal batteries have the highest potential efficiency, with no mass overhead.
Challenges in Achieving High-Capacity Batteries: Despite theoretical advantages, reaching high-capacity battery production remains a challenge. Amprius, a company founded by Steven Chu, has developed a mass-producing tool for silicon anodes.
The Ultimate Goal: All-Metal Batteries and Challenges: All-metal batteries have the highest potential efficiency, but lithium metal is very reactive. When charging rapidly or repeatedly, defects can occur in the solid electrolyte interphase (SEI) layer, leading to dendrite formation.
Addressing Dendrite Formation in Metal Batteries: Researchers have developed a cobalt polymer interface layer to prevent dendrite formation. This layer is stronger than the traditional SEI layer and can be used at elevated temperatures.
Challenges in Battery Temperature Management: Batteries perform poorly at very high and low temperatures. Keeping batteries at optimal temperatures requires using battery power to heat or cool them. This can be a significant drawback for electric vehicles in extreme weather conditions.
Research Directions and Ongoing Efforts: Ongoing research aims to develop battery materials that work effectively across a wide range of temperatures. The goal is to create batteries that can withstand both hot and cold climates without significant performance degradation.
00:29:17 Emerging Trends in the Transition from Internal Combustion Engines to Electric Vehicles
Steven Chu’s Observations on Electric Vehicles and Fuel Cells: Electric vehicle predictions are changing rapidly, with uptake predicted to be five times faster in 2016 than in 2015. Performance issues and infrastructure development are key challenges for electric vehicles to become widely adopted. Environmental pollution, particularly from horse manure and urine in the late 19th century, drove the transition from horse-drawn vehicles to automobiles. Recent medical research has revealed the dangers of nitrogen oxides and particulate matter, stimulating the demand for electric vehicles. China is the largest market for electric vehicles, with sales surpassing those of the United States, Canada, Mexico, and Europe combined. Fuel cell cars are commercially available and offer advantages such as faster refueling and longer range, but require a different infrastructure and clean hydrogen production. The real costs of fuel cell cars are not yet clear due to subsidies, and technological roadmaps are needed to assess their potential.
Air Pollution and Public Health: Air pollution, particularly particulate matter (PM2.5), has been linked to increased chances of lung cancer. The World Health Organization’s standard for clean air is 10 micrograms of PM2.5 per cubic meter, but the average air quality in Beijing often exceeds this level.
00:37:10 Nanofiber Filtration for Air Pollution Control
Air Filtration: PM2.5 particles are extremely harmful, with exposure equivalent to smoking a pack of cigarettes a day. Most home ventilation systems are inadequate in filtering out these fine particles. Electrospun nanofibers can effectively filter out PM2.5 particles, allowing 30% light transmission while capturing over 98% of the particles. The mechanism involves static electricity, where charged nanofibers polarize neutral particles, attracting and trapping them.
Electrochemistry: Electrochemistry becomes more affordable with low electricity costs, enabling various applications. Chong Liu’s work demonstrates the use of electrolysis to capture uranium efficiently. By applying a charge, uranium ions are attracted to a surface, where they undergo a chemical reaction to form a neutral uranium oxide. Reversing the electric field removes other ions, while the uranium remains attached. This process allows for the buildup of macroscopic thickness of uranium, making extraction more efficient.
Lithium Extraction: Given the uncertainty of uranium’s future, Steven Chu and his colleagues explored the possibility of using electrochemistry for lithium extraction. Lithium is a crucial component in batteries for electric vehicles and energy storage systems. Electrochemistry offers a potential method for extracting lithium from various sources, including seawater and brines. Research is ongoing to develop and optimize electrochemical processes for efficient and cost-effective lithium extraction.
00:42:34 Lithium Extraction and Carbon Dioxide Conversion
Lithium Price and Demand Projections: Lithium prices have increased significantly between July 2013 and 2016 due to speculation and high demand. Projections for EV demand indicate a substantial increase in lithium demand by 2030, potentially exceeding the current graph by a factor of 20.
Lithium Abundance in the Earth’s Crust: Lithium is abundant in the Earth’s crust, comparable to nitrogen and chlorine. However, lithium is not easily separated from ores, making extraction challenging.
Lithium Sources: Current sources of lithium include mineral ores, salty lake brines, and seawater. Seawater contains vast amounts of lithium, approximately 10,000 times more than current sources.
Seawater Extraction Method: A new method has been developed to extract lithium from seawater efficiently. In one cycle, the method can concentrate lithium from a molar concentration of 1 in 20,000 to 1 to 1.
Flowback Water as a Potential Source: Flowback water from oil drilling in Texas and Oklahoma contains high concentrations of lithium. Extracting lithium from flowback water can potentially generate significant revenue.
Carbon Dioxide Conversion: A new project aims to convert carbon dioxide into hydrogen and carbon monoxide using electrochemistry. This method eliminates the need for dissolving carbon dioxide in water, reducing the footprint and energy requirements.
Key Factors in Electrolysis Cost: The cost of electrolysis is primarily influenced by the footprint of the electrolysis process and the electricity required. Optimizing the footprint and utilizing renewable energy sources can significantly reduce electrolysis costs.
00:47:54 Electrochemical Pathways to a Clean Energy Future
Electrochemical Efficiency and Plant Size: The size of the electrochemical plant is crucial for cost-effectiveness. Compact and high-density plants are necessary to reduce capital expenditure (CAPEX). Planar geometry should be avoided to minimize mass transport friction and bubble formation energy.
Mimicking Lung Geometry for Efficient CO2 Reduction: A VLI (vascularized liquid-liquid interface) chamber is proposed to mimic the geometry of the lung. The VLI chamber consists of a series of pipes with decreasing sizes, similar to alveoli in the lungs. This design allows efficient contact between water and CO2, facilitating the desired electrochemical reactions.
Supercooled Sulfur and Its Unique Properties: Sulfur droplets in an electrolyte can be supercooled to room temperature and even lower (down to -30°C). This supercooled state of sulfur is unique, with a high degree of supercooling compared to its melting temperature. The supercooling is attributed to the lack of surface wetting and impurities, preventing nucleation and crystallization.
Potential Applications of Supercooled Liquids: Supercooled liquids, including water, can be obtained by preventing surface nucleation. This opens up possibilities for studying renormalization theories and fundamental physics. Measuring the viscosity of supercooled liquids using optical techniques provides insights into their physical properties.
Electrochemistry as a Key Technology for Clean Energy: Electrochemical processes play a vital role in converting captured CO2 into valuable chemicals. The initial step involves converting CO2 into hydrogen and carbon monoxide (CO). This process can be followed by splitting water to produce hydrogen and oxygen, leading to the formation of liquid hydrocarbons. Electrochemistry enables the efficient storage and transportation of clean energy in the form of chemical fuels.
Economic Advantages of Liquid Hydrocarbon Fuels: Liquid hydrocarbons, such as gasoline and diesel, offer significant economic advantages for energy storage and transportation. The cost of shipping and storing liquid hydrocarbons is relatively low compared to other forms of energy. This makes liquid hydrocarbons a practical and cost-effective solution for large-scale energy distribution.
Conclusion: Electrochemistry is a promising and versatile technology that holds the key to clean energy production, CO2 recycling, and the phase-out of fossil fuels. By mimicking natural systems like the lung and harnessing the unique properties of supercooled liquids, electrochemistry offers innovative solutions for a sustainable energy future.
Abstract
Electrochemistry: The Pivotal Force in Shaping a Sustainable and Clean Energy Future
In the face of escalating climate change risks, electrochemistry emerges as a cornerstone in the global transition towards sustainable energy. As the planet grapples with rising temperatures, melting glaciers, and soaring greenhouse gas emissions, the role of electrochemistry becomes increasingly vital. This article delves into the interconnected fields of climate change, renewable energy, and advanced energy storage solutions, highlighting how electrochemistry is not just enhancing energy storage through developments in battery technology and energy density but also driving forward novel methods for CO2 conversion and lithium extraction. Moreover, it underscores the significance of this field in addressing the urgent need for clean and efficient energy sources, the challenges and advancements in electric and fuel cell vehicles, and the innovative approaches to mitigate air pollution.
Article Body:
Climate Change Risks and the Imperative for Electrochemistry
Since 1975, Earth’s average global temperature has been rising alarmingly, accompanied by significant melting of glaciers and ice sheets, especially in Antarctica. This change is predominantly driven by the escalating emissions of greenhouse gases, chiefly CO2, which are rapidly nearing critical thresholds. Despite advancements in fossil fuel extraction technology, the urgent need to shift to sustainable energy solutions is becoming increasingly evident. In this context, agriculture and land use, including methane emissions from cows and overfertilization, have also been major contributors to greenhouse gases, with impacts comparable to those of the electricity sector.
The Evolution of Renewable Energy and Electrochemistry’s Role
The cost-effectiveness of renewable energy sources, such as wind and solar, has significantly improved, making them increasingly competitive with traditional fossil fuels. Particularly notable is the affordability of offshore wind energy, which has fewer siting constraints and is becoming competitive with nuclear power, albeit with subsidies. Electrochemistry plays a pivotal role in energy storage, a key aspect for integrating renewable energy into the grid. This is evident from the advancements in battery technology and fuel cells. Moreover, machine learning is emerging as a significant tool in managing the complex distribution system of a grid with high renewable energy content.
Electrochemistry in Energy Storage: Advancements and Challenges
The energy storage domain has witnessed significant improvements in the affordability and energy density of batteries, enhancing their viability. Lithium-ion battery manufacturers have made strides by delivering samples with an energy density of 750 watt-hours per liter, a remarkable increase from the initial 250 watt-hours per liter. However, lithium-sulfur batteries and advanced designs are facing challenges such as stability and volume changes, despite their promising energy density. Metal batteries, known for their high potential efficiency, are grappling with issues like reactivity and dendrite formation. The theoretical efficiency of battery materials varies significantly, with silicon showing a much higher potential efficiency compared to metal. However, achieving high-capacity battery production, especially with silicon anodes, remains a challenge, despite ongoing developments in mass-production tools. All-metal batteries, the ultimate goal in this field, face challenges due to the reactivity of lithium metal and defects in the solid electrolyte interphase layer, leading to dendrite formation. Researchers are making progress by developing interface layers, such as a cobalt polymer layer, that are more robust than the traditional SEI layer and can operate at elevated temperatures. Battery temperature management is another significant challenge, as batteries perform poorly in extreme temperatures, which is a drawback for electric vehicles in harsh weather conditions. To overcome this, research is focused on developing battery materials that can operate effectively across a wide temperature range, thereby creating batteries that can withstand both hot and cold climates without significant performance degradation.
Innovations in Battery Technology and Electric Vehicles
The field of battery technology is witnessing rapid advancements, fueling optimism for higher energy densities in the near future. Electric vehicle adoption forecasts have been revised upwards, driven by increasing concerns over air pollution and health, and the recognition of the cost competitiveness of renewable energy sources. The transition from traditional to electric vehicles is akin to the historical shift from horse-drawn carriages to automobiles, necessitating significant infrastructure changes. China’s dominance in the electric vehicle market signifies a global shift towards cleaner transportation. Electric vehicle predictions have evolved rapidly, with the uptake forecasted to be five times faster in 2016 than in 2015. Performance issues and infrastructure development are critical challenges for the widespread adoption of electric vehicles. Environmental pollution, highlighted by the issues of horse manure and urine in the late 19th century, catalyzed the transition to automobiles. Recent medical research shedding light on the dangers of nitrogen oxides and particulate matter has stimulated the demand for electric vehicles. China has emerged as the largest market for electric vehicles, with sales surpassing those of the United States, Canada, Mexico, and Europe combined. Fuel cell cars, while commercially available and offering benefits like faster refueling and longer range, still face challenges in terms of infrastructure requirements and clean hydrogen production. The real costs of fuel cell cars remain uncertain due to subsidies, and technological roadmaps are essential to assess their potential.
Air Pollution, Health Concerns, and Electrochemical Solutions
Recent studies have underscored the severe health risks associated with particulate matter, especially PM2.5. Electrochemistry’s potential in combating air pollution is evident through innovations like electrospun nanofibers for efficient PM2.5 filtration. The work of Nobel laureate Steven Chu in using electric fields for particle polarization has been instrumental in developing effective air filters. PM2.5 particles pose extreme health hazards, comparable to the effects of smoking a pack of cigarettes a day. Most home ventilation systems are inadequate at filtering out these fine particles. Electrospun nanofibers, however, have shown remarkable effectiveness in filtering out PM2.5, allowing 30% light transmission while capturing over 98% of the particles. The mechanism involves static electricity, where charged nanofibers polarize neutral particles, attracting and trapping them.
Electrochemistry in Resource Extraction and Carbon Capture
With the rising demand for lithium in electric vehicles, innovative methods for efficient lithium extraction from seawater have been developed. Designs inspired by lung geometry in compact electrolysis plants show promise for efficient mass transport and reduced capital expenditures. Electrochemistry also plays a central role in converting CO2 into hydrogen and carbon monoxide, providing a cleaner approach to resource utilization. Electrochemistry becomes more affordable with lower electricity costs, enabling a variety of applications. Chong Liu’s work demonstrates efficient uranium capture through electrolysis. By applying a charge, uranium ions are attracted to a surface, undergoing a chemical reaction to form neutral uranium oxide. Reversing the electric field removes other ions while the uranium remains attached, allowing for the accumulation of macroscopic thickness of uranium, making extraction more efficient. Considering the uncertainty of uranium’s future, Steven Chu and his colleagues have explored electrochemistry for lithium extraction. Lithium is essential in batteries for electric vehicles and energy storage systems. Ongoing research aims to develop and optimize electrochemical processes for efficient and cost-effective lithium extraction from various sources, including seawater and brines.
Electrochemistry as a Catalyst for Sustainable Change
Electro chemistry’s diverse applications, spanning energy storage, electric vehicles, carbon capture, and resource extraction, underscore its integral role in steering the world away from fossil fuels. By offering solutions to the pressing challenges of climate change and renewable energy integration, electrochemistry stands as a key player in the journey towards a cleaner, more sustainable future. This field not only enhances our understanding of energy storage and conversion but also drives innovation in reducing environmental impact and improving efficiency. The advancements in electrochemistry are pivotal in shaping a sustainable and clean energy future, highlighting its importance in the global effort to combat climate change and promote environmental sustainability.
Elon Musk's battery project in Australia aims to stabilize the grid and combat climate change, while the country grapples with an energy crisis and rising power poverty. Despite political skepticism, public support for renewable energy solutions remains strong....
Technological advancements in energy storage and renewable energy sources like wind and solar offer solutions to climate change and energy accessibility challenges. Renewable energy technologies are becoming increasingly cost-effective, driving the transition towards a sustainable future....
Long-duration energy storage (LDES) is vital for balancing intermittent renewable energy sources and maintaining grid stability, but current technologies face scalability, efficiency, and cost challenges. Innovations in flow batteries, thermal storage, hydrogen, and utility-scale batteries offer promise, but technical, economic, transmission, and environmental issues must be addressed for widespread adoption....
Climate change demands international collaboration among scientists, economists, and social scientists to develop technology roadmaps for net-zero emissions and sustainable practices in sectors like energy, agriculture, and industry. A shift towards renewable energy, energy storage solutions, and advanced agricultural practices is crucial for a sustainable future....
Amory Lovins emphasizes energy efficiency and renewable energy integration as key to a sustainable future, while electric vehicles and innovative battery technologies can disrupt traditional energy industries....
Government programs and global collaborations have driven advancements in clean energy, but challenges remain in energy storage and renewable energy penetration. Technological innovations like battery cost reduction and carbon pricing are key to driving meaningful change in climate action....
Energy transitions are complex and involve more than just replacing fossil fuels with renewables, requiring a multifaceted approach including efficiency improvements and policy changes. Despite the push for renewables, fossil fuels remain vital due to their energy density, necessitating efficient use through regulations and technology....