Stephen Hawking (University of Cambridge Professor) – White House Millennium Lecture Series (Apr 2012)
Chapters
00:00:10 Scientific Discovery and the Future of Physics
Speaker Introductions: Stephen Hawking, Lucasian Professor of Mathematics at Cambridge University, is introduced by the speaker. Hawking will deliver the second Millennium Lecture at the White House.
Audience: The lecture is being broadcast live via satellite to audiences at 190 downlinks in 43 states. Thousands more are watching via the Internet, C-SPAN, and the BBC.
Importance of Science and Math Education: President Clinton emphasizes the importance of providing future leaders with the best possible education in science and math.
Hawking’s Accomplishments: Hawking has spent a lifetime unlocking the mysteries of the universe. He has received numerous honors, including being inducted into the Royal Academy in London. His book, “A Brief History of Time,” is the best-selling science book ever written.
Hawking’s Communication System: Hawking has ALS, also known as Lou Gehrig’s disease. He communicates through a customized computer system that enables him to select words from the bottom of his computer screen and send them to a speech synthesizer.
Hawking’s Legacy: Hawking embodies the enduring spirit of imagination and sees no boundaries. He has expanded the domain of physics to audiences like us.
00:10:39 Future of Science and Technology: Uncertainties and Possibilities
Static Visions of the Future: Traditional portrayals of the future in science fiction often depict a static, near-perfect society far advanced in science, technology, and organization.
Exponential Growth: Hawking challenges this notion, asserting that history shows constant knowledge and technological advancements with exponential growth in recent times. Measures like population growth, electricity consumption, and scientific publications demonstrate this exponential trend, doubling every 40 years or less.
Current Discontent: Despite this growth, people feel cheated by the lack of utopian visions from the past, such as moon bases and manned flights to Jupiter.
Impossibility of Continued Exponential Growth: Hawking argues that the current exponential growth cannot continue indefinitely due to physical limitations and information overload.
Potential Outcomes: One possibility is a catastrophic self-destruction, such as a nuclear war, due to civilization’s inherent instability at this stage of development. While Hawking believes there’s another explanation for the lack of extraterrestrial contact, he refrains from discussing it in this segment.
Hawking warns of the real danger of self-destruction now that humanity possesses the technological power to do so. Even if complete annihilation is avoided, a descent into a brutal and barbaric state, similar to the opening scene of Terminator, is a possibility.
Hawking’s Optimism and Predictions: Despite the risks, Hawking remains optimistic that both Armageddon and a new dark age can be averted. Predicting scientific and technological developments over the next millennium is challenging, but Hawking offers his forecasts. While his predictions for the next century may have a chance of being accurate, those for the remainder of the millennium are speculative.
The Roots of Modern Science: Modern scientific understanding emerged around the time of the European settlement of North America. In 1679, Isaac Newton, a Cambridge professor, published his theory of gravity. In 1864, Clerk Maxwell, another Cambridge scientist, discovered the equations governing electricity and magnetism.
Classical Laws and the Understanding of the Universe: By the late 19th century, it seemed possible to achieve a complete understanding of the universe using classical laws. Classical laws align with common sense notions that physical quantities like position, speed, and rotation should be well-defined and continuously variable.
Common Sense Vs. Quantum Theory: Stephen Hawking challenges the notion of common sense as a reliable guide to understanding the universe, highlighting the counterintuitive nature of quantum mechanics.
Quantum Theory: A New Paradigm: Quantum mechanics emerged in the early 20th century to explain observations that defied classical physics, such as the quantization of energy.
Uncertainty and Multiple Histories in Quantum Theory: In quantum theory, particles lack a single, unique history, instead having every possible history with varying probabilities. This uncertainty becomes significant at the atomic and subatomic levels, unlike macroscopic systems like baseball games.
Feynman’s Sum Over Histories: Richard Feynman introduced the concept of summing over all possible histories to calculate probabilities in quantum theory.
Paths Beyond the Speed of Light and Time Travel: Quantum theory allows for paths that travel faster than light and even paths that go back in time, but these are not practical for time travel.
Virtual Particles in Empty Space: Even seemingly empty space is filled with particles moving in closed loops in space and time, with both forward and backward time components. These virtual particles have observable consequences, as demonstrated by the Casimir effect, where a small force pushes metal plates together due to the reduction of closed loops between them.
Infinite Possibilities and the American Budget: The infinite number of closed loops of particles in space and time poses a mathematical challenge, similar to the American budget, where subtracting one infinity from another yields a finite result.
00:29:19 Supersymmetry and the Search for a Unified Theory of Physics
Challenges in Unifying Quantum Theory and Relativity: Difficulties arise when attempting to combine quantum theory with Einstein’s general relativity due to an infinite number of closed loops causing trouble.
Supersymmetry and Grassman Dimensions: Supersymmetry, a new concept in nature, was proposed as a solution to the infinite energy issue. Grassman dimensions, extra dimensions measured using Grassman numbers, were introduced as part of this theory.
Super-partner Species and Energy Cancellation: Each species of particle has a super-partner species with closed loops of particles that have opposite energy signs. This leads to a tendency for infinite energies to cancel out.
Progress and the Holy Grail of Physics: There has been progress in understanding the universe, from classical physics to atomic, nuclear, and high-energy physics. Although the ultimate goal, unifying Einstein’s general relativity with quantum theory, remains elusive, it is believed to be achievable.
The Planck Length as a Limit: There is a limit to the series of discovering structures on smaller length scales, known as the Planck length, which is extremely small.
Testing Supersymmetry and the Superconducting Supercollider: Supersymmetry is fundamental to unifying general relativity and quantum theory and can be tested by finding superpartners of known particles. The superconducting supercollider, which could have tested this, was canceled, a decision considered short-sighted.
Future Prospects for Discovery: Observational evidence from the Big Bang and mathematical beauty and consistency will play a role in discovering the ultimate theory of everything. The prediction is that the theory will be discovered by the end of the 21st century, possibly within 20 years.
00:38:35 Biological Evolution and the Future of Genetic Engineering
Biological Evolution: Biological evolution, proposed by Charles Darwin, is a slow process of increasing complexity in DNA through natural selection of mutations. The complexity of DNA is measured by the number of bits of information coded in it, roughly equivalent to the number of nucleic acids in the molecule.
DNA Complexity Increase: Initially, the rate of increase in DNA complexity was very slow, estimated at one bit of information every hundred years for the first two billion years. Over the last few million years, the rate has gradually increased to approximately one bit per year.
Genetic Engineering: We are now entering a new era where we can increase the complexity of our DNA without relying on slow biological evolution. Genetic engineering on humans is likely to become a reality in the next thousand years, despite potential ethical concerns.
00:44:25 Technological Progress and the Future of Humanity
Genetic Engineering and Human Enhancement: Genetic engineering on plants and animals is likely to be allowed for economic reasons. Someone will eventually attempt human genetic engineering, leading to the development of “improved humans.” Hawking emphasizes that this is not a desirable outcome but a probable reality.
Complexity and Intelligence: The human race needs to enhance its mental and physical qualities to cope with the increasingly complex world and challenges like space travel. Biological systems must outpace electronic ones in terms of complexity to maintain dominance.
Moore’s Law and Exponential Growth: Computers have a speed advantage but lack intelligence due to their lower complexity compared to even simple organisms like earthworms. Moore’s Law predicts that computer speed and complexity will double every 18 months, leading to exponential growth. This growth cannot continue indefinitely, but it will likely continue until computers reach a complexity similar to the human brain.
Artificial Intelligence and Complexity: Some argue that computers can never exhibit true intelligence. Hawking believes that complex electronic circuits can imitate the intelligence of complex chemical molecules in humans. If computers become intelligent, they can design even more complex and intelligent computers, leading to a cycle of increasing complexity.
Rapid Increase in Complexity: Hawking challenges the static depiction of the future in science fiction, predicting a rapid increase in complexity in both biological and electronic spheres. While significant changes may not occur in the next hundred years, the transformation will be fundamental by the end of the millennium.
Political and Technological Implications: Hawking believes the present world order has a future, but it will undergo significant changes due to technological advancements. He emphasizes the importance of reconciling the infinitesimal with the infinite to achieve a theory of everything. Hawking’s insights have challenged notions of time and eternity, inspiring a dynamic and human-centered vision of the future.
00:54:26 Theoretical Physics and Its Profound Questions
Unpredictable Discoveries: Stephen Hawking believes the most exciting cosmological discoveries will be unexpected, as they have been in the past.
Anthropic Principle: William Phillips proposes that the universe follows mathematical laws because any different laws would have prevented the evolution of life and the ability to ask such questions, known as the anthropic principle.
Genetic Engineering: Francis Collins acknowledges the potential of genetic engineering to eradicate diseases and alleviate suffering but cautions against its misuse. Collins emphasizes the moral and ethical implications of using genetic engineering to enhance human beings, such as defining what constitutes an improvement. He warns against further discrimination between the haves and have-nots and stresses the need for public involvement to ensure that technology serves humanity rather than dominating it.
Humble Perspective: Stephen Hawking expresses humility when compared to Newton and Einstein, stating that the media hype surrounding him is due to his fit within the popular stereotype of a mad scientist or disabled genius.
Message from Space: Astronaut Andrew Thomas, orbiting Earth on the space station Mir, sends a special message from outer space.
Exploration and Education: Thomas emphasizes the importance of encouraging students to participate in space exploration-related activities.
Combining Past and Future: He believes these activities serve to honor the past and envision the future of space exploration.
Promoting Student Participation: Thomas expresses gratitude for the students’ participation in the event and calls for continued support of science education.
01:04:42 Emergence of the Unexpected in Scientific Discovery
In his response to a question from Sakeel Moyo, Professor Hawking stated that observations suggest there isn’t enough matter in the universe to stop its expansion. He noted that if there is additional undetected dark matter, the universe could collapse in a “big crunch,” ending the universe and time itself. He clarified that there doesn’t seem to be a way to progress from the “big crunch” to a new “big bang,” providing some relief that this event is at least 20 billion years away.
Dr. Andrea Dupree’s Comment: Dr. Dupree reflected on the rapid pace of scientific understanding and development, particularly in astrophysics. She emphasized the unexpected discoveries made using the Hubble Space Telescope, such as observing the surface of a star from the time of Christopher Columbus’ arrival in America. She concluded that basic research is essential for preparing for the unexpected and gaining a better understanding of our place in the universe.
01:07:37 Scientific Breakthroughs and Questions from the Millennium Symposium
Stephen Hawking discusses recent observational evidence suggesting the existence of an anti-gravitational force causing the universe to expand at an accelerating rate. Einstein initially proposed the concept but later regretted it, considering it his greatest mistake. If present, the anti-gravitational force is likely very small, making it challenging to understand why unless it is precisely zero. Confirmation or refutation of this force may require observations from new satellites launched by the US and Europe in the early years of the new millennium. Analysis of satellite data would necessitate a supercomputer like the National Cosmology Computer in Cambridge, UK. Verification of an anti-gravitational force would imply that inflation is a natural law.
The Power of the Heart and Spirit President Clinton acknowledges Vice President Gore’s absence due to obligations in New Hampshire, jokingly attributing it to a unique gravitational force in the state. Clinton expresses his opposition to the cancellation of the Superconducting Super Collider (SSC) project, reiterating the administration’s support for the Swiss project that aims to fill the gap. Clinton acknowledges the numerous questions from the audience and expresses his interest in exploring the implications of a multidimensional understanding of time and space and advanced computers on our notions of time and communication. Clinton emphasizes Hawking’s status as a living miracle, highlighting the power of the heart and spirit amidst the technological marvels that enabled Hawking’s communication with the audience. Clinton expresses his hope that scientific advancements will amplify the heart and spirit witnessed during the evening.
Abstract
The Visionary World of Stephen Hawking: A Journey Through Science and Imagination (Updated)
In a groundbreaking lecture at the White House, Stephen Hawking, a towering figure in modern physics, presented a vision that stretched from the intricacies of quantum mechanics to the vast expanse of the universe. His talk, marked by President Clinton’s introduction and broadcast globally, delved into the evolution of the universe, the potential of genetic engineering, and the challenges and promises of technological advancements. Hawking’s unique ability to communicate complex concepts, despite his physical limitations due to ALS, made the event not just a scientific discourse but an inspirational journey. This article encapsulates Hawking’s profound insights, exploring his predictions, the interplay of quantum theory and relativity, the prospects of genetic engineering, and the philosophical underpinnings of his work.
Introduction of Hawking and the Millennium Lecture Series:
Stephen Hawking, the Lucasian Professor of Mathematics at Cambridge University, delivered an impactful second Millennium Lecture at the White House. This lecture, embracing the modern reach of technology and media, was broadcast live to a diverse audience across 43 states through 190 downlinks and reached thousands more globally via the Internet, C-SPAN, and the BBC. President Clinton, recognizing the event’s significance, underscored the vital role of science and math education in shaping future leaders.
Stephen Hawking’s Accomplishments:
Stephen Hawking’s life has been a testament to exploring the universe’s mysteries. His significant contributions have been recognized widely, including his induction into the Royal Academy in London. His profound impact on popularizing science is best exemplified by his book “A Brief History of Time,” which stands as the best-selling science book ever written.
Hawking’s Communication System:
Afflicted with ALS, also known as Lou Gehrig’s disease, Hawking has relied on a customized computer system to communicate. This system allows him to select words from a screen and articulate them through a speech synthesizer, a testament to his determination to overcome physical barriers.
1. A Glimpse into Hawking’s Universe
Stephen Hawking’s lecture, a cornerstone of the Millennium Lecture series, showcased his journey from a young enthusiast to a leading figure in cosmology. His commitment to demystifying the cosmos is evident in his bestselling “A Brief History of Time.” His lecture, focusing on imagination and change, acknowledged the rapid technological growth, highlighting both its potential challenges and the human spirit’s capacity for knowledge and innovation.
2. The Future as Envisioned by Hawking
Hawking, addressing a global audience, pondered a future shaped by population and technological growth. He warned of self-destruction and barbarism due to technology, yet remained hopeful about humanity’s ability to avert these dangers. His predictions covered a wide range, from the possibility of extraterrestrial contact to the future of genetic engineering, highlighting both the opportunities and risks ahead.
3. Quantum Theory and the Fabric of Reality
Hawking challenged the reliability of common sense in understanding the universe, pointing to the counterintuitive nature of quantum mechanics. Quantum theory, emerging in the early 20th century, was developed to explain phenomena that classical physics could not. It posits that particles lack a single history and exist in multiple histories with varying probabilities, a concept significant at the atomic and subatomic levels. Richard Feynman’s introduction of summing over all possible histories to calculate probabilities in quantum theory marked a critical advancement. Quantum theory even allows for paths faster than light and paths that travel back in time. In seemingly empty space, particles move in closed loops, both forward and backward in time, a phenomenon observable in effects like the Casimir effect. The mathematical challenge presented by these infinite closed loops is akin to the complexity of the American budget.
4. Unifying Quantum Mechanics and General Relativity
Combining quantum theory with Einstein’s general relativity presents challenges due to the infinite number of closed loops causing issues. Supersymmetry, introducing concepts like Grassman dimensions, emerged as a solution to the infinite energy problem. Each particle species has a super-partner species, leading to a cancellation of infinite energies. While the ultimate goal of unifying these two theories remains elusive, there has been significant progress, and the Planck length sets a limit on discovering smaller structures. The superconducting supercollider, which could have tested supersymmetry, was unfortunately canceled. Nevertheless, the pursuit of the ultimate theory continues, with the expectation of a breakthrough within the 21st century.
5. The Evolution of Complexity and Genetic Engineering
Hawking discussed the evolution of DNA complexity, as proposed by Charles Darwin, highlighting its slow increase through natural selection. The rate of DNA
complexity increase accelerated significantly in the last few million years. With the advent of genetic engineering, we now have the capability to further increase our DNA’s complexity without relying solely on biological evolution. Hawking predicted that genetic engineering in humans will likely become a reality within the next thousand years, despite ethical concerns.
6. Hawking’s Legacy and Philosophical Musings
Hawking’s talk not only illuminated his scientific achievements but also reflected on his personal journey and philosophical insights. He discussed his role in the scientific community, his media portrayal, and his thoughts on the ethical dimensions of advancements, especially in genetics. His confidence in visualizing mathematical concepts and his aspiration to discover a complete theory of the universe were particularly notable.
7. Concluding Thoughts: The Universe’s Expansion and the Unknown
Hawking concluded his lecture with thoughts on the universe’s expansion, considering the existence of dark matter and the possibility of a “Big Crunch.” He also discussed recent evidence of an anti-gravitational force, underscoring the need for more research and observations. This conclusion underscored his philosophy of relentless knowledge pursuit, combined with the wisdom to understand its implications.
Supplemental Update Sections
Genetic Engineering and Human Enhancement
Genetic engineering is expected to be applied to plants and animals for economic reasons, leading to the eventual attempt at human genetic engineering. This development could result in “improved humans,” a prospect Hawking regarded as probable but not necessarily desirable.
Complexity and Intelligence
To cope with an increasingly complex world and challenges like space travel, Hawking emphasized the need for the human race to enhance its mental and physical qualities. He suggested that biological systems must surpass electronic ones in complexity to maintain dominance.
Moore’s Law and Exponential Growth
Hawking discussed Moore’s Law, which predicts the doubling of computer speed and complexity every 18 months, leading to exponential growth. He noted that this growth, while not infinite, could continue until computers reach complexity comparable to the human brain.
Artificial Intelligence and Complexity
Hawking believed that complex electronic circuits could potentially imitate human intelligence. The advent of intelligent computers could trigger a cycle of increasing complexity, with computers designing even more advanced systems.
Rapid Increase in Complexity
Hawking predicted a rapid increase in complexity in both biological and electronic spheres, challenging the static future often depicted in science fiction. He envisioned significant changes by the end of the millennium.
Political and Technological Implications
Hawking foresaw significant changes to the current world order due to technological advancements. He highlighted the need to reconcile the infinitesimal with the infinite in the pursuit of a theory of everything.
Unpredictable Discoveries
Hawking believed that the most exciting cosmological discoveries would likely be unexpected, echoing the patterns of past discoveries.
Anthropic Principle
William Phillips proposed the anthropic principle, suggesting that the universe follows mathematical laws because any different laws would have prevented life’s evolution and our ability to ask such questions.
Genetic Engineering
Francis Collins discussed genetic engineering’s potential to eradicate diseases but cautioned against its misuse. He highlighted the moral and ethical implications of using it to enhance human beings.
Humble Perspective
Hawking expressed humility when compared to Newton and Einstein, attributing the media hype around him to his fit within the stereotype of a mad scientist or disabled genius.
Message from Space
Astronaut Andrew Thomas sent a special message from the space station Mir, emphasizing the importance of encouraging student participation in space exploration.
Exploration and Education
Thomas stressed the value of involving students in space exploration activities, seeing it as a way to honor the past and envision the future of space exploration.
Promoting Student Participation
Thomas expressed gratitude for student involvement in the event and called for continued support of science education.
The Existence of an Anti-Gravitational Force
Hawking discussed recent evidence for an anti-gravitational force, acknowledging its potential to cause an accelerating expansion of the universe. This concept, initially proposed by Einstein, remains challenging to understand and requires further research.
The Power of the Heart and Spirit
President Clinton spoke about Vice President Gore’s absence and the cancellation of the Superconducting Super Collider project. He emphasized Hawking’s status as a living miracle, showcasing the power of the heart and spirit amidst technological advancements.
Stephen Hawking’s lecture at the White House transcended academic discourse, exemplifying the human spirit’s quest for cosmic understanding. His journey from curiosity to esteemed physicist serves as a beacon of inspiration, reminding us of our capacity for intellectual exploration and the complex mysteries of the universe awaiting our discovery.
Stephen Hawking's lecture at the Institute for Advanced Study in Hong Kong explored the origins and nature of the universe, touching on topics like the Big Bang, quantum mechanics, and the significance of universal constants. Hawking's insights highlighted the importance of combining general relativity and quantum theory to understand the...
Stephen Hawking discussed the universe's origin, fate, and the possibility of multiple histories, comparing it to a giant casino governed by probabilities. He proposed a unified theory of everything that would explain the universe's beginning and boundary conditions....
Stephen Hawking's journey from an uninspired student to a renowned theoretical physicist was marked by a life-altering diagnosis and remarkable achievements, revolutionizing our understanding of cosmology and inspiring a global interest in science. Hawking's contributions extended beyond his scientific achievements, as he emphasized the significance of space exploration and encouraged...
Physicist Stephen Hawking spoke at a conference about his resilience against motor neuron disease, scientific breakthroughs, and space exploration despite his condition. Hawking's journey of overcoming physical limitations with technology, his contributions to science, and his advocacy for focusing on abilities rather than disabilities were highlighted....
The universe's origin is a tapestry of ancient creation myths, philosophical ideas, and scientific theories, with the Big Bang theory as the prevailing explanation for its beginning and expansion. Physicist Stephen Hawking's work, including the South Pole analogy and quantum creation, proposes the universe's spontaneous emergence from quantum processes....
Despite a debilitating disease, Stephen Hawking made groundbreaking contributions to cosmology and black hole physics, challenging existing ideas and reshaping our understanding of the universe. His emphasis on scientific communication and public engagement made complex scientific concepts accessible, inspiring future generations of scientists....
Stephen Hawking challenged traditional views of the universe's origin, proposing a scientific interpretation combining general relativity and quantum theory. His work on inflation suggests the universe spontaneously created itself from nothing, governed by scientific laws....