Jennifer Doudna (UC Berkeley Professor) – CRISPR Cas9 (Apr 2021)
Chapters
00:00:25 CRISPR Genome Editing: From Discovery to Clinical Trials
Background of CRISPR: CRISPR is a powerful gene editing tool that enables precise modifications to genomes. The discovery of CRISPR was an example of serendipitous scientific exploration, revealing unexpected natural phenomena.
Harnessing CRISPR for Genome Editing: CRISPR-Cas9, a key component of the CRISPR system, was identified as a programmable genome editing tool. The protein Cas9, guided by an RNA molecule, can recognize and cut specific DNA sequences.
Current Research and Clinical Applications: Ongoing research aims to understand how CRISPR works and how it can be safely and effectively used in clinical settings. Clinical trials utilizing CRISPR technology are underway, targeting various diseases.
00:06:18 CRISPR-Cas9: A Powerful Genome Editing Tool
Background: CRISPR-Cas9 is a programmable adaptive immune system used by bacteria to fight infection. In the mid-2000s, scientists discovered that bacteria adapt DNA sequences in real time as they are exposed to viruses, suggesting a potential mechanism for storing genetic information from viruses and using it to protect cells.
CRISPR Mechanism: When bacteria are infected by a virus, they can acquire a new sequence of viral DNA and integrate it into a special place in their genome. The cell makes an RNA copy of the CRISPR sequence, which is processed into shorter bits that each include a sequence derived from a virus. Together with a second RNA called tracer and the protein Cas9, this RNA-guided surveillance complex searches the cell for a DNA sequence that matches the RNA guide. When a match occurs, Cas9 unwinds the DNA and cuts it, allowing the DNA to be degraded.
Application in Plant and Animal Cells: The double-stranded DNA cutting activity of CRISPR-Cas9 can be harnessed in plant, animal, and human cells. When DNA double-stranded breaks occur in eukaryotic cells, the cell can recognize and repair the break, introducing small disruptions or integrating new genetic material at the site of the break. CRISPR-Cas9 can be easily reprogrammed by simply changing the guide RNA, making it a versatile tool for targeted DNA editing.
CRISPR-Cas9 Mechanism in Eukaryotic Cells: CRISPR-Cas9 protein with its guide enters the nucleus of a eukaryotic cell and surveys the sequence to identify a sequence that matches the RNA guide. DNA unwinding occurs locally, allowing Cas9 to cut the DNA double helix precisely. Broken ends of DNA are handed off to repair enzymes in the cell, which can fix the break or integrate a new piece of DNA.
CRISPR-Cas9 Adoption and Impact: After its publication in 2012, CRISPR-Cas9 was rapidly adopted by multiple labs worldwide. Eight years later, CRISPR-Cas9 has become a powerful tool for genetic editing with applications in research, medicine, and agriculture.
Cross-Cutting Applications: CRISPR is not just used in medicine but also has applications across biology, including basic research, agriculture, and medicine. The ability to manipulate DNA in cells has opened up access to genetic information in the human genome and other genomes.
Somatic Cell Editing in Medicine: Clinical applications of CRISPR often involve somatic cell editing, where cells are corrected in a patient and used to treat their disease. For example, in sickle cell disease, CRISPR can correct the mutation that causes the disease or activate the production of a healthy form of hemoglobin.
Benefits and Challenges of Somatic Cell Editing: Somatic cell editing allows for precise targeting of specific cells and DNA sequences. The challenge lies in delivering the CRISPR components to the correct cells and ensuring safe and efficient editing without causing unintended consequences.
CRISPR for Cancer Immunotherapy: CRISPR can be used to modify T cells to target and eliminate cancer cells more effectively. This approach, known as CAR T cell therapy, has shown promising results in clinical trials. However, challenges remain in controlling the activity of CAR T cells and ensuring their safety.
Gene Editing in Agriculture: CRISPR has applications in agriculture to improve crop yields and resistance to pests and diseases. Gene-edited crops can be produced with enhanced nutritional content and resistance to environmental stresses. The use of gene editing in agriculture raises ethical and regulatory considerations.
00:13:55 CRISPR: Precision Gene Editing, Ethical Considerations, and Clinical Applications
CRISPR: An Exciting New Therapy for Treating Genetic Diseases: CRISPR-based gene therapies have shown promising results in clinical trials. Victoria Gray, the first US patient to receive CRISPR therapy for sickle cell disease, has experienced significant improvement. CRISPR has the potential to treat various rare diseases that were previously difficult to address.
Ensuring Affordability and Accessibility: Current CRISPR therapies are expensive, limiting their accessibility. Efforts are underway to make CRISPR technology more affordable and accessible to a broader population.
Ethical Considerations for Human Germline Applications: CRISPR technology raises ethical concerns when applied to the human germline, potentially impacting future generations. International discussions are ongoing to establish guidelines and ensure responsible use of CRISPR in this context.
Research Challenges and Ongoing Developments: Researchers are working to improve the accuracy and efficiency of CRISPR for clinical applications. Base editors, a modified form of CRISPR-Cas9, can convert specific nucleotides in DNA, enabling precise chemical editing. Challenges include optimizing the speed and effectiveness of these editors for clinical use.
Structural Insights into Base Editor Mechanism: Collaboration between Jennifer Doudna’s lab and others led to the discovery of an efficient base editor called ABE8E. ABE8E exhibits unique kinetics and specificity compared to other base editors. Cryo-electron microscopy revealed the structural details of ABE8E bound to DNA, providing insights into its mechanism of action.
00:26:50 Molecular Mechanism and Evolution of CRISPR-Cas Systems
Molecular Adaptation of TAD-A Base Editor: TAD-A base editor, an improved version of the original base editor, exhibits increased specificity for DNA editing over RNA editing. Mutations in TAD-A cluster in the region responsible for DNA binding, suggesting adaptation to a DNA substrate. TAD-A’s efficiency in editing DNA may lead to unwanted off-target edits and requires further optimization.
Understanding Molecular Mechanisms Guides Technology Development: Analyzing the molecular mechanism of CRISPR-Cas proteins helps guide the direction and development of CRISPR-Cas technology. Researchers seek to strike a balance between editing speed and specificity to minimize off-target effects.
Exploring Alternative CRISPR-Cas Systems: Beyond Cas9, researchers are investigating diverse CRISPR-Cas systems found in nature, including those present in bacteriophages. These alternative systems, such as CasP, offer unique properties and potential applications.
CasP: A Compact and Efficient CRISPR-Cas System: CasP, a compact CRISPR-Cas system found in phage, has a small size and a single guide RNA. Despite its small size, CasP is capable of targeted double-stranded DNA cutting and inducing genome editing in human cells. Its simplicity and efficiency make CasP an attractive candidate for further study and potential applications.
00:31:08 CRISPR Delivery Methods: Virus-Like Particle Encapsulation of Pre-Assembled
Structural Insights into CasB Protein: Cryo-electron microscopy reveals the tight interaction between CasB protein, guide RNA, and targeted DNA. Detailed understanding of DNA recognition and unwinding mechanisms in CRISPR-Cas systems. Identification of a naturally inhibitory structure that regulates CasB activity.
Challenges in CRISPR-Cas Delivery: Current bottleneck in CRISPR field is selective delivery of editing enzymes to specific cell types. Bone marrow transplantation in CRISPR-based treatments highlights the need for safer delivery methods.
Exploring Novel Delivery Strategies: Development of virus-like particles (VLPs) as delivery vehicles for CRISPR-Cas9 proteins and guide RNAs. VLPs are engineered to target specific cell types and release their contents inside the cells. Fusion of Cas9 to a chimeric GAG protein ensures efficient encapsulation and release of the editing complex.
Proof of Concept: Successful expression of chimeric antigen receptors in targeted T cells using VLP-mediated delivery. Selective targeting of CD4-positive T cells in a mixed cell population demonstrates the potential for precise cell-type editing.
Future Potential: VLP-based delivery holds promise for targeted editing of clinically beneficial cells while leaving bystander cells unmodified. Ongoing research aims to refine and optimize this strategy for future therapeutic applications.
00:39:30 CRISPR-Based Protein Delivery and Clinical Testing for Neurological Diseases and Pandemics
Protein RNA Delivery for Genome Editing in the Brain: Jennifer Doudna discusses a promising approach for genome editing in the brain using protein RNA delivery. Engineered Cas9 peptides with cell-penetrating properties allow direct protein delivery across the blood-brain barrier. Dose-dependent editing is observed, with higher amounts of engineered Cas9 leading to increased editing efficiency. This strategy shows potential for targeted delivery and may be useful for treating neurodegenerative diseases like Parkinson’s.
CRISPR and Coronavirus: During the COVID-19 pandemic, the Innovative Genomics Institute set up a clinical testing lab using standard PCR-based technology. The lab is clinically approved and provides testing services for the university campus and collaborates with various organizations. The lab’s efforts contribute to monitoring and understanding the spread of the virus, aiding in pandemic response.
00:42:08 CRISPR Applications in Healthcare Diagnostics
CRISPR for Testing and Diagnostics: CRISPR can be utilized for testing and diagnostics due to its unique chemistry.
CRISPR-Cas13: CRISPR-Cas13 is a type of protein that naturally targets RNA. Upon recognition of a target sequence, CRISPR-Cas13 activates a non-specific RNA-cutting activity, releasing a fluorescent signal. This strategy has been widely adopted for diagnostic purposes.
CRISPR-Cas12: CRISPR-Cas12 is another class of enzymes with similar capabilities to CRISPR-Cas13. CRISPR-Cas12 targets DNA sequences and activates a DNA-cutting activity upon binding.
CRISPR for Virus Detection: CRISPR can be used to detect viruses, particularly RNA viruses like the coronavirus. CRISPR-based tests offer advantages in quantification and speed compared to traditional methods.
Clinical Testing: The author’s lab is preparing to use a CRISPR-based laboratory test for coronavirus. This test will be evaluated in a beta test site with a local company developing the technology.
00:45:36 CRISPR Technology: Challenges and Considerations for Future Development
Points Raised by Jennifer Doudna: The continued study of genome editing systems will enable the development of more efficient and accurate genome editing proteins. The discovery of new, compact genome editors can offer new clinical strategies, particularly for delivery. Improved methods for delivering genome editing proteins, especially in situ, are crucial for advancing this technology as a clinical therapy.
Question and Answer Highlights: Jennifer Doudna expresses concerns about the rapid advancement of CRISPR technology and emphasizes the need for appropriate caution and restraint in conducting clinical trials. Accessibility is another concern for Doudna. She believes the technology should be more affordable and accessible for it to impact those who need it. The challenge of directing therapeutics to specific cells is acknowledged, and Doudna highlights the importance of engineering approaches to achieve cell specificity. The vast potential of undiscovered phages and their functionalities is discussed, indicating the immense opportunities for further research in this area. The possibility of anti-drug antibody responses is raised, and Doudna confirms that this is a valid concern due to the use of foreign proteins in genome editing. Collaboration with immunology labs is underway to investigate this aspect in mouse models.
Concluding Remarks: Jennifer Doudna concludes her presentation by acknowledging her team’s contributions and expressing gratitude to her collaborators and supporting agencies. She also mentions that the photograph shown represents a pre-pandemic team, highlighting the impact of the pandemic on research activities.
00:51:42 Advanced Research in CRISPR-Cas9 and Its Variants
Immunogenicity and Engineering of CRISPR-Cas Proteins: CRISPR-Cas proteins, particularly those from bacterial sources, can be immunogenic in humans. Researchers are exploring ways to engineer these proteins to reduce immunogenicity and make them more “humanized,” similar to approaches used for antibodies.
Safety Considerations: CRISPR-Cas systems derived from phages that do not infect bacteria related to human physiology may be intrinsically safer due to the absence of pre-existing antibodies in humans.
Non-Invasive mRNA Delivery for Self-Antigens: Researchers are developing non-inflammatory mRNA-based methods to induce tolerance to key proteins targeted by CRISPR-Cas systems.
Challenges in Understanding Cas9’s Target-Finding Mechanism: The human genome’s large size poses a challenge in understanding how Cas9 finds its target sequences. Single-molecule imaging techniques are being employed to study Cas9’s movements and target recognition in real time.
Cas9’s Target Recognition Efficiency: Cas9 must rapidly scan and locate its target sequences among numerous potential sites within a cell. Understanding the underlying mechanisms of Cas9’s target recognition is crucial for improving its efficiency and specificity.
Imaging Advancements for Studying Cas9’s Genome Travel: Recent advancements in imaging technology allow researchers to visualize Cas9 as it travels across the genome, providing insights into its target-finding process.
Selection of Cas9: Among various Cas enzymes (Cas12, Cas6, Cas13, and Cas9), Cas9 was chosen due to its ease of use, high efficiency, and adaptability to different experimental systems.
00:55:08 CRISPR-Cas: Ethical and Patent Considerations
Origin of CRISPR Research: Jennifer Doudna and Emmanuelle Charpentier collaborated to investigate the CRISPR system in Streptococcus pyogenes. Cas9 was identified as a key protein with RNA targeting capability, but its biochemical mechanism was unknown.
Diversity of CRISPR Systems: CRISPR systems exhibit extensive diversity, particularly in the Cas12 family of proteins. The existence of Cas proteins beyond Cas24 is uncertain, and if they exist, they are likely rare.
Evolution of CRISPR-Cas Genes: Laboratory evolution has been instrumental in identifying variants of CRISPR genes with desired functions.
Ethical Considerations: Concerns about the potential misuse of CRISPR-Cas technology, such as rogue editing of human embryos, have been raised. The need for strong global scientific community standards to guide the ethical application of the technology is emphasized.
Intellectual Property and Patenting: The challenge lies in balancing the need for wide adoption and rapid development of CRISPR technology with the rights of investors and commercial ventures. Ongoing patent disputes have not hindered the scientific progress and application of CRISPR-Cas technology.
Abstract
Harnessing CRISPR: The Cutting-Edge of Genetic Editing – Updated Article
CRISPR-based gene therapies have demonstrated promising results in clinical trials, exemplified by the remarkable improvement seen in Victoria Gray, the first US patient to receive CRISPR therapy for sickle cell disease. This breakthrough offers renewed hope for addressing various rare diseases that were previously challenging to treat.
Despite these advancements, affordability and accessibility remain significant hurdles. Current CRISPR therapies are expensive and may not be readily accessible to all patients. Recognizing this disparity, efforts are underway to make CRISPR technology more affordable and equitable, ensuring broader access to this life-changing therapy.
The application of CRISPR technology to the human germline raises profound ethical considerations, given its far-reaching implications. International discussions are ongoing to establish guidelines and ensure responsible use of CRISPR in this context.
Research endeavors continue to refine the accuracy and efficiency of CRISPR for clinical applications. Base editors, modified forms of CRISPR-Cas9, offer precise chemical editing by converting specific nucleotides in DNA. While promising for treating a wide range of genetic diseases, challenges remain in optimizing their speed and effectiveness for clinical use.
In a significant breakthrough, Jennifer Doudna’s lab, in collaboration with others, discovered an efficient base editor called ABE8E. ABE8E exhibits unique kinetics and specificity compared to other base editors. Cryo-electron microscopy revealed the structural details of ABE8E bound to DNA, providing insights into its mechanism of action and paving the way for further refinement and optimization.
Beyond the Cas9 system, researchers are exploring diverse CRISPR-Cas systems found in nature, including those present in bacteriophages. These alternative systems, such as CasP, offer unique properties and potential applications. CasP, a compact and efficient CRISPR-Cas system found in phage, possesses a small size and a single guide RNA. Despite its simplicity, CasP is capable of targeted double-stranded DNA cutting and genome editing in human cells, making it an attractive candidate for further study and potential applications.
A comprehensive understanding of the molecular mechanisms underlying CRISPR-Cas proteins guides the advancement of CRISPR-Cas technology. By analyzing these mechanisms, researchers can strike a balance between editing speed and specificity, minimizing off-target effects and enhancing the overall efficacy of the technology.
Structural insights into the CasB protein, revealed through cryo-electron microscopy, provide a deeper understanding of DNA recognition and unwinding mechanisms in CRISPR-Cas systems. Furthermore, the identification of a naturally inhibitory structure that regulates CasB activity offers insights for modulating CRISPR-Cas activity and improving its controllability.
A significant bottleneck in the CRISPR field lies in the selective delivery of editing enzymes to specific cell types. Bone marrow transplantation in CRISPR-based treatments underscores the need for safer delivery methods that minimize off-target effects and ensure precise targeting of the desired cells.
Addressing this challenge, researchers are exploring novel delivery strategies, such as virus-like particles (VLPs) as delivery vehicles for CRISPR-Cas9 proteins and guide RNAs. Engineered to target specific cell types, VLPs release their contents inside the cells, enabling precise editing of the desired genetic material.
Proof-of-concept studies have successfully demonstrated the expression of chimeric antigen receptors in targeted T cells using VLP-mediated delivery. This approach allows for selective targeting of specific cell types within a mixed cell population, highlighting the potential for precise cell-type editing.
VLP-based delivery holds promise for targeted editing of clinically beneficial cells while leaving bystander cells unmodified. Ongoing research aims to refine and optimize this strategy for future therapeutic applications, paving the way for a new era of targeted and effective gene editing.
Novel Genome Editing Strategies
Protein RNA Delivery for Genome Editing in the Brain:
Jennifer Doudna’s innovative approach using protein RNA delivery offers promising prospects for genome editing in the brain. Engineered Cas9 peptides with cell-penetrating properties enable direct protein delivery across the blood-brain barrier. Dose-dependent editing is observed, with higher amounts of engineered Cas9 leading to increased editing efficiency. This strategy shows potential for targeted delivery and may be useful for treating neurodegenerative diseases like Parkinson’s.
CRISPR and Coronavirus:
During the COVID-19 pandemic, the Innovative Genomics Institute established a clinically approved testing lab utilizing standard PCR-based technology. This lab provides testing services for the university campus and collaborates with various organizations, contributing to the monitoring and understanding of the virus spread and aiding in pandemic response.
CRISPR’s Role in Testing and Diagnostics
CRISPR for Testing and Diagnostics:
CRISPR’s unique chemistry lends itself to applications in testing and diagnostics. CRISPR-Cas13, a protein that naturally targets RNA, activates a non-specific RNA-cutting activity upon recognizing a target sequence, releasing a fluorescent signal. This strategy has been widely adopted for diagnostic purposes.
CRISPR-Cas12, another class of enzymes with similar capabilities to CRISPR-Cas13, targets DNA sequences and activates a DNA-cutting activity upon binding. Both CRISPR-Cas13 and CRISPR-Cas12 offer advantages in sensitivity and specificity compared to traditional methods.
CRISPR for Virus Detection:
CRISPR can be employed for virus detection, particularly RNA viruses like the coronavirus. CRISPR-based tests provide advantages in quantification and speed compared to traditional methods.
Clinical Testing:
The author’s lab is preparing to use a CRISPR-based laboratory test for coronavirus. This test will undergo evaluation in a beta test site with a local company developing the technology.
Jennifer Doudna’s Concluding Remarks and Q&A
Jennifer Doudna emphasized the need for continued study of genome editing systems to develop more efficient and accurate genome editing proteins. She highlighted the potential of compact genome editors, like CasP, for new clinical strategies, particularly in terms of delivery.
Concerns were raised about the rapid advancement of CRISPR technology, accessibility, and the challenge of directing therapeutics to specific cells. Doudna emphasized the importance of appropriate caution and restraint in conducting clinical trials, addressing accessibility issues, and engineering approaches for cell specificity.
The vast potential of undiscovered phages and their functionalities was discussed, indicating immense opportunities for further research. Anti-drug antibody responses were acknowledged as a valid concern, and collaborations with immunology labs were mentioned to investigate this aspect in mouse models.
Jennifer Doudna concluded her presentation by acknowledging her team’s contributions and expressing gratitude to her collaborators and supporting agencies. She also highlighted the impact of the pandemic on research activities.
Supplemental Information
Immunogenicity and Engineering of CRISPR-Cas Proteins:
CRISPR-Cas proteins, particularly those from bacterial sources, can be immunogenic in humans. Researchers are exploring ways to engineer these proteins to reduce immunogenicity and make them more “humanized,” similar to approaches used for antibodies.
Safety Considerations:
CRISPR-Cas systems derived from phages that do not infect bacteria related to human physiology may be intrinsically safer due to the absence of pre-existing antibodies in humans.
Non-Invasive mRNA Delivery for Self-Antigens:
Researchers are developing non-inflammatory mRNA-based methods to induce tolerance to key proteins targeted by CRISPR-Cas systems.
Challenges in Understanding Cas9’s Target-Finding Mechanism:
The human genome’s large size poses a challenge in understanding how Cas9 finds its target sequences. Single-molecule imaging techniques are being employed to study Cas9’s movements and target recognition in real time.
Cas9’s Target Recognition Efficiency:
Cas9 must rapidly scan and locate its target sequences among numerous potential sites within a cell. Understanding the underlying mechanisms of Cas9’s target recognition is crucial for improving its efficiency and specificity.
Imaging Advancements for Studying Cas9’s Genome Travel:
Recent advancements in imaging technology allow researchers to visualize Cas9 as it travels across the genome, providing insights into its target-finding process.
Selection of Cas9:
Among various Cas enzymes (Cas12, Cas6, Cas13, and Cas9), Cas9 was chosen due to its ease of use, high efficiency, and adaptability to different experimental systems.
Origin of CRISPR Research:
Jennifer Doudna and Emmanuelle Charpentier collaborated to investigate the CRISPR system in Streptococcus pyogenes. Cas9 was identified as a key protein with RNA targeting capability, but its biochemical mechanism was unknown.
Diversity of CRISPR Systems:
CRISPR systems exhibit extensive diversity, particularly in the Cas12 family of proteins. The existence of Cas proteins beyond Cas24 is uncertain, and if they exist, they are likely rare.
Evolution of CRISPR-Cas Genes:
Laboratory evolution has been instrumental in identifying variants of CRISPR genes with desired functions.
Ethical Considerations:
Concerns about the potential misuse of CRISPR-Cas technology, such as rogue editing of human embryos, have been raised. The need for strong global scientific community standards to guide the ethical application of the technology is emphasized.
Intellectual Property and Patenting:
The challenge lies in balancing the need for wide adoption and rapid development of CRISPR technology with the rights of investors and commercial ventures. Ongoing patent disputes have not hindered the scientific progress and application of CRISPR-Cas technology.
CRISPR technology has revolutionized genetic engineering, enabling precise DNA modifications with potential for treating genetic diseases and developing novel therapies, but ethical and regulatory considerations are essential. CRISPR's versatility extends beyond DNA editing, with applications in RNA targeting and genome editing in various organisms, raising ethical questions about its use...
The CRISPR-Cas9 system, pioneered by Jennifer Doudna, revolutionized genome editing with its ability to target specific DNA sequences, opening up new avenues in biomedical research and gene therapy. CRISPR-Cas9's dual RNA-guided DNA cleaving mechanism enables precise genome editing and has profound implications in the fields of medicine and genetics....
CRISPR-Cas9, a revolutionary gene-editing technology, allows precise editing of DNA, with applications in treating genetic diseases, enhancing agricultural practices, and potentially improving human traits. CRISPR-Cas9 can be used to make targeted changes in the microbiome, potentially benefiting human health and reducing environmental impact....
CRISPR-Cas9 technology revolutionized gene editing with its precise modifications of DNA, but raises ethical questions regarding its use and potential consequences. Scientists, audiences, and regulators must engage in responsible discussions to guide ethical development and application of CRISPR....
CRISPR-Cas9, pioneered by Jennifer Doudna, revolutionized gene editing, enabling precise DNA manipulation with implications for medicine, agriculture, and research. The technology's ethical considerations, such as germline editing and designer babies, necessitate responsible progress and discussion....
CRISPR-Cas9 revolutionizes genome editing and expands its applications. CRISPR-Cas9's versatility raises ethical and societal concerns, necessitating responsible management of its technology....
CRISPR-Cas systems are adaptive immune responses in bacteria that protect against viruses by cleaving foreign DNA. CRISPR-Cas9 technology allows for precise genome editing in eukaryotic cells, raising ethical considerations and the need for responsible progress....