Vinod Khosla (Khosla Ventures Founder) – Health 2.0 Silicon Valley Meet-up (Jul 2014)
Chapters
00:00:17 Digital Health: Radical Opportunity for New Science, Medicine, and Startups
—
Radical Opportunity: Digital health offers radical opportunities, with two categories: support in IT and inventing the science of medicine. Both present significant startup possibilities.
Changing Healthcare Paradigm: Most of what doctors do today, including diagnosis, prescription, and monitoring, may be eliminated.
Increased Accessibility: Healthcare costs will decrease, becoming essentially free and providing near-equal access worldwide.
Patient Empowerment: Consumers will become CEOs of their health, empowered by information and becoming more informed than their doctors.
Shifting Doctor’s Role: Doctors’ roles will change from providers of care to mentors, guiding patients through illnesses and making ethical decisions.
Reevaluating Medical Education: Medical school admissions may prioritize emotional intelligence (EQ) over intellectual quotient (IQ) to select future doctors.
Global Impact: Digital health advancements will extend benefits to underserved areas, making healthcare accessible globally.
Embracing Uncertainty: While predictions may be inaccurate, the current healthcare system will not persist indefinitely.
00:05:16 Future of Healthcare: Innovation Powered by Mobile and Data
Investment Timing: Khosla believes it’s easier to predict the directionality of trends than specific details, and he acknowledges the inherent uncertainty in making specific predictions.
Current Opportunities in Healthcare: Khosla emphasizes the current time as an ideal period for investing in healthcare, especially for those interested in innovation, driving change, and contributing to medical advancements.
Comparison to Technology: Khosla highlights the disparity between the computing power dedicated to webpage ads and medical decisions, emphasizing the need for more sophisticated systems and machine learning in healthcare.
Prevalence of Medical Errors: Khosla draws attention to the alarming rate of medical errors, particularly in the ICU, which surpasses the mortality rate of breast cancer in the United States.
Technological Advancements: He discusses the convergence of mobile computing, affordable sensors, and advancements in machine learning and data science as key enablers for transformative changes in healthcare.
Sensors and Data: Khosla shares his personal experience using a prototype device that generated 10 million data points per day, far exceeding the limited data typically collected during doctor visits.
Nexus of Opportunities: He likens the current healthcare landscape to a stool that gains stability with three or more legs, emphasizing the combination of sensors, mobile computing, and machine learning as a foundation for significant opportunities.
00:09:07 Mobile Healthcare Innovations: Empowering Personalized and Continuous Health Monitoring
Investment Insights: Vinod Khosla highlights several significant investments with impactful potential, including AliveCore, Ginger.io, and Cellscope.
AliveCore’s Innovation: AliveCore integrates an ECG machine into an iPhone case, enabling convenient, affordable, and frequent heart monitoring.
Benefits of Continuous Monitoring: Frequent EKG readings empower individuals to monitor their heart health proactively and detect potential issues earlier.
Automated Diagnosis: With a vast database of EKGs, AliveCore can perform automatic diagnosis, offering real-time insights and guidance.
Accessible Healthcare: AliveCore’s solution provides access to cardiology expertise at a fraction of the cost of traditional hospital EKGs.
Extending the Trend: Similar innovations are emerging in mental health (Ginger.io) and specialized healthcare areas like ENT and dermatology (Cellscope).
Innovation Potential: Every medical specialty presents opportunities for innovation, inviting more individuals to contribute to the transformation of healthcare.
00:12:03 Innovation in Healthcare Beyond Digital Health
Startup Innovations: Vinod Khosla highlights innovations across various sectors, including healthcare, biology, and chemistry. New developments in physics and chemistry are particularly promising. Examples include reimagined food products like eggs, beef, and salt, driven by fundamental science. A shift in focus from enterprise software to physics and chemistry driven innovation.
Importance of Outcomes in Investments: When investing, Khosla emphasizes the significance of improving outcomes over reducing costs. Positive outcomes lead to greater impact and, eventually, financial success. Mission-driven entrepreneurs tend to outperform mercenary-driven ones in the long run.
Hospitals and Health Plans Building Digital Health Technologies: Khosla questions the success of large institutions in building digital health technologies. Partnering with institutions can help startups overcome challenges and accelerate progress.
Square’s Success Story: Khosla shares the story of Square’s early success in the payments industry. Square’s founder, Jack Dorsey, attributed their success to hiring individuals with fresh perspectives, not burdened by existing industry knowledge. This approach allowed them to challenge conventional practices and disrupt the market.
00:16:58 Advice from a Successful Entrepreneur: Embracing Innovation, Breaking Rules, and Maintaining a
Key Points: Importance of Fresh Thinking: Vinod Khosla emphasizes the significance of approaching innovation with a fresh perspective. He believes that entrepreneurs who are unburdened by preconceived notions and experiences often have a higher chance of success. Rethinking Established Processes: Khosla advocates for the reinvention of processes from scratch to pave the way for groundbreaking advancements. He encourages entrepreneurs to question traditional methods and explore new possibilities. Self-Confidence and Openness to Input: To navigate the complex entrepreneurial landscape, Khosla suggests that individuals should cultivate a combination of self-confidence and skepticism. The ability to trust one’s instincts while remaining open to feedback is crucial for effective decision-making. The Best Decision: Khosla highlights the importance of making bold decisions in life. He shares that his choice to immigrate to the United States at the age of 16, inspired by Andy Grove’s story, turned out to be the best decision he made, alongside marrying his wife. Breaking Rules and Challenging Norms: Khosla stresses the importance of nonconformity in entrepreneurship. He believes that breaking established rules, even those that may be culturally ingrained, can lead to groundbreaking ideas and ventures. Schizophrenic Personality of Entrepreneurs: To succeed as an entrepreneur, Khosla emphasizes the need for a unique blend of optimism, self-confidence, and paranoia. This paradoxical combination allows entrepreneurs to balance risk-taking with a healthy dose of skepticism. Recommended Reading: Khosla recommends Andy Grove’s book, “Only the Paranoid Survive,” as an invaluable resource for aspiring entrepreneurs. The book offers insights into the mindset and strategies required for entrepreneurial success.
00:20:50 Entrepreneurial Tactics and Vision in Healthcare Technology
Global Healthcare Needs Drive Innovation: * Countries like India, with rapidly growing economies and limited healthcare services, present substantial opportunities for innovative healthcare solutions.
Considering Value and Opportunity in Adjacent Markets: * While charging more may be challenging in markets with limited resources, the potential for creating valuable services and generating revenue exists. * Administrative systems, like ZocDoc, can bring efficiency and revenue generation to healthcare providers without directly contributing to medical science.
Disruptive Innovation and Nonlinear Changes: * Dentistry, like other medical fields, has the potential for nonlinear changes in practice, although specific examples are not yet evident. * Sensors, data science, and mobile technology may play significant roles in transforming dental practices.
Validation from Other VCs: * Vinod Khosla emphasizes the importance of independent thinking in venture capital. * Successful investments often stem from having an opinion that differs from others and being proven right.
Embracing Failure as a Tool: * Khosla encourages entrepreneurs to view failure as a valuable learning experience, rather than something to be avoided. * Doing things, experimenting, and iterating are more effective than planning or relying solely on expert forecasts.
Entrepreneurs’ Vision and Tactics: * Entrepreneurs should be persistent in pursuing their long-term vision but flexible in their approach. * Achieving a stable base camp, or intermediate goal, is crucial before pursuing the larger vision. * Entrepreneurs should focus on securing resources and building momentum rather than solely pursuing profitability.
Healthcare Access and Opportunity: * In underserved regions, where access to healthcare is limited, mobile health apps and innovative solutions have a significant opportunity. * The uninsured population in developed countries presents a similar opportunity, as they are more likely to rely on mobile healthcare solutions.
00:33:04 Investment Innovation for the Average Person
Opportunities for the Average Investor: There is a lack of reliable investment advice accessible to the average person, leading them to seek guidance from unqualified sources like talk shows or uninformed friends.
Innovative Solutions: Good systems can address this issue by providing reliable advice to a broader audience.
Machine Learning in Investing: Quantopian, a Boston-based company, harnesses the expertise of top machine learning professionals to create robust algorithms. These algorithms are showcased on Quantopian’s website, along with their performance history, enabling investors to make informed decisions.
Democratizing Investment Advice: Quantopian disrupts the traditional investment landscape by eliminating intermediaries and allowing any investor to subscribe to its services. This creates an eBay-like platform for wealth investors, where algorithms serve as fund managers, providing unbiased advice based on performance data.
Future Outlook: Khosla predicts that, within five years, the advice offered on platforms like Quantopian will surpass that of traditional financial institutions. This democratization of investment advice will benefit those with limited resources, offering them access to unbiased and transparent guidance.
00:35:05 The Future of Behavior Modification Through Software
Behavior Modification in Healthcare: Vinod Khosla stresses the importance of behavioral medicine, urging entrepreneurs to focus on behavior modification rather than just selling devices. He emphasizes asking what daily changes users experience when using a medical device, as the product’s success lies not in the hardware but in the achieved behavior change.
WellDoc’s Success: Khosla cites WellDoc as a prime example of behavior modification’s impact in healthcare. WellDoc’s software app, approved by the FDA as a pharmaceutical drug, achieved higher blood sugar reduction than traditional drugs like Fortinet and Metformin.
Challenges in Software Drugs: Khosla highlights the challenges faced by WellDoc, such as the need for refills every three months and a formulary price of $180 per month, despite its effectiveness.
Two Approaches to Behavior Modification:
Khosla outlines two approaches to behavior modification in healthcare: 1. Bucking the system and focusing solely on behavior modification, such as with Jenny Craig. 2. Following the full FDA process, as WellDoc did, requiring partnerships and clinical trials similar to those for chemical drugs.
Software Drugs in Mental Health: Khosla predicts software drugs will be prevalent in mental health, surpassing traditional drugs like Valium and Ritalin. He believes software apps can effectively address various mental health issues, from wellness and focus apps to clinical disorders and depression.
Business Planning: Khosla encourages entrepreneurs to prioritize thinking through issues rather than creating a business plan. He suggests that the value of a business plan lies in its ability to address key issues and facilitate effective decision-making.
00:38:43 Technology-Enabled Behavior Modification: Possibilities and Challenges
Highlighted VC Insights: Vinod Khosla advises entrepreneurs to consider all factors affecting their business and recommends the book “Lean Startup” for guidance on practical iterations and learning. Different apps and approaches to behavior modification are more effective for different individuals. Ginger.io collects thousands of data points daily to track mental health, offering potential for predictive behavior modification and treatment. Wearables can effectively modify behavior, such as Jawbone’s reminder to move. The effectiveness of weight loss apps varies among individuals.
Examples of Behavior-Modifying Technologies: Think, a company developing a headset that electrically stimulates the brain, allowing users to experience the effects of coffee or meditation. Advertisers use data analysis and machine learning to hack the human brain for marketing purposes. Behavior modification through brain hacking has ethical implications and the potential to influence preferences and behaviors.
VC Evaluation of Plans: VCs are diverse with different strategies and preferences, making it difficult to characterize a “good” or “bad” VC. Poorly presented plans may be disregarded, as VCs prioritize signals of thoughtfulness and clarity. Entrepreneurs should learn from rejection and solicit feedback even if they aren’t actively seeking funding.
Data Aggregation Trends: Data aggregation will likely become a valuable function with various service providers entering the market. Consumers will ultimately decide the preferred form of data aggregation, such as federation or affiliation.
00:49:37 Key Factors in Startup Investment Decisions
Investment Approach: Khosla Ventures invests in a wide range of businesses, from those with clear business models to those focused solely on significant technical innovation. Investments range from $100,000 to $50 million. Key criteria include the quality of the team, their innovative thinking, and their vision for the future.
Team and Idea Quality: Khosla emphasizes the importance of exceptional teams and their ability to think deeply and present problems effectively. The firm actively seeks out talented individuals and welcomes resumes, business plans, and feedback.
Focus on Successful Companies: Khosla criticizes VCs who prioritize management fees over building successful companies. He believes that many VCs are focused on the right approach, which is fostering the growth of strong, thriving businesses.
Understanding the FDA’s Perspective: Khosla acknowledges the frustrations entrepreneurs may face when dealing with the FDA. He emphasizes the FDA’s cautious approach, driven by the need to avoid mistakes that could lead to media scrutiny and firings. He highlights examples of FDA approvals, such as LDOC and over-the-counter ECG machines, demonstrating their willingness to embrace innovation.
FDA’s Constraints and Innovative Thinking: Khosla explains that the FDA’s constraints differ from those in Silicon Valley, impacting their decision-making process. He commends the FDA for their innovative thinking, particularly in cases where the potential harm is minimal.
Contact Information: Khosla encourages attendees to email him directly at vk@coastaladventures.com for any inquiries or feedback. He emphasizes his commitment to responding to every email he receives.
Abstract
“Revolutionizing Healthcare: How Digital Innovation and Entrepreneurial Vision are Shaping the Future”
In a groundbreaking analysis, Vinod Khosla’s insights into digital health reveal a transformative era in healthcare, poised to redefine patient care and medical practice. Central to this transformation is the convergence of computing power, mobile technology, and machine learning, catalyzing advancements from continuous heart monitoring (AliveCore) to mental health interventions (Ginger.io). Khosla’s vision extends to a future where healthcare is universally accessible, and patients become the CEOs of their own health, empowered by predictive care and advanced technology. This shift not only promises radical changes in medical roles, emphasizing ethical decision-making over routine tasks, but also necessitates a reevaluation of medical education, prioritizing emotional intelligence. Amidst these seismic shifts, challenges in the bureaucratic nature of hospitals and health plans emerge, alongside the potential for disruptive innovation in every medical specialty.
Main Ideas and Expansion:
Digital Health’s Transformative Opportunities:
Digital health is at the forefront of revolutionizing healthcare, offering significant administrative improvements and advancements in medical science. Healthcare costs will likely decrease substantially, approaching a near-free state, with access becoming more equitable worldwide. The consumer’s role is expected to evolve dramatically, becoming the central figure in managing their health, backed by enhanced information and predictive care. This paradigm shift predicts a fundamental change in the doctor’s role, focusing more on ethical decision-making and mentorship.
Moreover, innovations across sectors, including healthcare, biology, and chemistry, hold immense promise. New developments in physics and chemistry, such as reimagined food products like eggs, beef, and salt, driven by fundamental science, exemplify this potential. A shift from enterprise software to physics and chemistry-driven innovation reflects the evolving landscape of innovation.
Khosla’s Vision for Healthcare Innovation:
Khosla identifies a unique opportunity in healthcare, likening it to a stable three-legged stool supported by advancements in computing, affordable sensors, and machine learning. He highlights the alarming rate of medical errors and the transformative potential of these technologies to improve patient outcomes. His vision is characterized by a commitment to innovation, especially in the context of healthcare software in developing countries. Khosla emphasizes the current time as an ideal period for investing in healthcare, particularly for those interested in innovation, driving change, and contributing to medical advancements.
When investing, Khosla emphasizes the significance of improving outcomes over reducing costs. Positive outcomes lead to greater impact and, eventually, financial success. Mission-driven entrepreneurs tend to outperform mercenary-driven ones in the long run.
Case Studies in Innovation: AliveCore, Ginger.io, Cellscope:
Innovations like AliveCore’s ECG machine, Ginger.io’s mental health app, and Cellscope’s smartphone-based otoscope exemplify the breadth of digital health’s impact. These technologies democratize access to specialized care, offering continuous monitoring, personalized interventions, and remote examinations. Khosla shares his personal experience using a prototype device that generated 10 million data points per day, far exceeding the limited data typically collected during doctor visits.
Broader Innovation Beyond Digital Health:
Innovation in healthcare extends to fields like physics, chemistry, and biology. Khosla points out the reinvention of basic food items using scientific principles and the increasing demand for expertise in these areas. He argues that prioritizing patient outcomes over costs leads to greater long-term impact and financial success.
Challenges for Traditional Healthcare Institutions:
Hospitals and health plans face significant hurdles in adapting to digital health due to their size and bureaucratic nature. However, partnerships with innovative institutions can facilitate this transition. Khosla draws parallels with Square’s success in the payments industry, attributed to its disregard for legacy knowledge and norms.
Square’s founder, Jack Dorsey, attributed their success to hiring individuals with fresh perspectives, not burdened by existing industry knowledge. This approach allowed them to challenge conventional practices and disrupt the market.
Entrepreneurship and Innovation Perspectives:
Khosla emphasizes the value of breaking rules and maintaining a balance of optimism, self-confidence, and paranoia in entrepreneurship. His personal journey, inspired by Andy Grove, reflects the essence of innovative thinking, uninhibited by past experiences.
Khosla highlights the importance of innovations across sectors, the potential for value creation in adjacent markets, and the need for disruptive innovation in healthcare fields like dentistry. He emphasizes the role of entrepreneurs in pursuing their vision persistently while adapting their approach and securing resources. Khosla also stresses the importance of embracing failure as a learning opportunity and the need for independent thinking in venture capital.
Key Insights from Khosla’s Presentation:
Khosla discusses various aspects of healthcare technology startups, including the importance of systems that bring new solutions, the role of administrative systems in improving efficiency, and the need to address the needs of the uninsured. He also stresses the significance of embracing failure and avoiding herd mentality in entrepreneurship.
The Future of Investment and Healthcare Software:
Khosla’s insights extend to investment strategies, highlighting the value of technical innovations irrespective of immediate business models. He underscores the role of a strong team in realizing innovative ideas and acknowledges the FDA’s cautious yet progressive approach. While predictions may be inaccurate, the current healthcare system will not persist indefinitely.
Opportunities for the Average Investor:
Traditionally, reliable investment advice was inaccessible to the average person, often leading them to seek guidance from unqualified sources. Good systems can address this issue by providing reliable advice to a broader audience. Quantopian, a Boston-based company, showcases robust algorithms created by top machine learning professionals, allowing investors to make informed decisions based on performance history. By eliminating intermediaries, Quantopian democratizes investment advice, enabling any investor to subscribe to its services.
Software’s Role in Behavior Modification and Healthcare:
Vinod Khosla emphasizes the importance of behavioral medicine, urging entrepreneurs to focus on behavior modification rather than just selling devices. He highlights the success of WellDoc, a software app approved by the FDA as a pharmaceutical drug, which achieved higher blood sugar reduction than traditional drugs. Challenges faced by WellDoc, such as refill requirements and formulary price, underscore the need for practical solutions. Khosla outlines two approaches to behavior modification in healthcare: bucking the system and focusing solely on behavior modification or following the full FDA process. He predicts the prevalence of software drugs in mental health, effectively addressing various mental health issues.
VCs, Entrepreneurs, and Behavior Modification:
Khosla advises entrepreneurs to consider all factors affecting their business and recommends the book “Lean Startup” for guidance on practical iterations and learning. He emphasizes the effectiveness of different apps and approaches to behavior modification for different individuals. Citing examples like Think, which allows users to experience the effects of coffee or meditation, Khosla highlights the ethical implications of brain hacking for behavior modification. Entrepreneurs should learn from rejection and solicit feedback, regardless of their funding status. Data aggregation will likely become a valuable function, with consumers ultimately deciding the preferred form of data aggregation.
Supplemental Updates:
Investment Approach:
– Khosla Ventures invests in a wide range of businesses, from those with clear business models to those focused solely on significant technical innovation.
– Investments range from $100,000 to $50 million.
– Key criteria include the quality of the team, their innovative thinking, and their vision for the future.
Team and Idea Quality:
– Khosla emphasizes the importance of exceptional teams and their ability to think deeply and present problems effectively.
– The firm actively seeks out talented individuals and welcomes resumes, business plans, and feedback.
Focus on Successful Companies:
– Khosla criticizes VCs who prioritize management fees over building successful companies.
– He believes that many VCs are focused on the right approach, which is fostering the growth of strong, thriving businesses.
Understanding the FDA’s Perspective:
– Khosla acknowledges the frustrations entrepreneurs may face when dealing with the FDA.
– He emphasizes the FDA’s cautious approach, driven by the need to avoid mistakes that could lead to media scrutiny and firings.
– He highlights examples of FDA approvals, such as LDOC and over-the-counter ECG machines, demonstrating their willingness to embrace innovation.
FDA’s Constraints and Innovative Thinking:
– Khosla explains that the FDA’s constraints differ from those in Silicon Valley, impacting their decision-making process.
– He commends the FDA for their innovative thinking, particularly in cases where the potential harm is minimal.
Contact Information:
– Khosla encourages attendees to email him directly at vk@coastaladventures.com for any inquiries or feedback.
– He emphasizes his commitment to responding to every email he receives.
In conclusion, Khosla’s vision for healthcare represents a seismic shift towards a more accessible, efficient, and patient-centered system. His insights encourage a reimagining of healthcare roles, education, and the entrepreneurial mindset, underscoring the critical intersection of technology and healthcare. As the landscape of healthcare continues to evolve, these insights offer a roadmap for future innovations and a glimpse into a more equitable and effective healthcare system.
AI's transformative impact spans industries, promising innovation in healthcare, climate solutions, and the music industry, while also presenting challenges like job displacement and income inequality. Tech advancements, particularly AI, drive change, with India's young demographic poised to play a significant global role....
Vinod Khosla believes technology can solve global challenges and advocates for diverse thinking, risk-taking, and disruptive innovation to drive societal transformation. He envisions using technology to improve resource utilization and reduce environmental pressures, potentially enabling a resource-rich lifestyle for all....
Entrepreneurs should embrace failure, remain flexible, and prioritize learning over rigid planning to succeed in a dynamic business landscape. Venture capitalists play a crucial role in expanding an entrepreneur's thinking and providing growth opportunities....
Vinod Khosla's philosophy includes taking risks, embracing failure, and finding opportunities at the edges of systems to drive meaningful change through innovation and venture capital. He encourages cultivating a strong personal compass and belief system to challenge norms, embrace failure, and create a positive impact....
Vinod Khosla emphasized the transformative power of disruption and innovation, challenging conventional thinking and advocating for education focused on real-world problem-solving and accepting failure as part of the innovation process. He criticized traditional liberal arts education and proposed a curriculum focused on practical skills and knowledge, including STEM subjects, computer...
Vinod Khosla envisions a future transformed by AI, autonomous vehicles, 3D printing, and innovative approaches to healthcare, transportation, manufacturing, and education. He emphasizes the role of entrepreneurs and technology in revolutionizing societal infrastructure and improving quality of life for all....
Innovation and resilience are key ingredients for successful entrepreneurship, requiring a balance of values, risk-taking, and embracing failure to drive societal progress....