Vitalik Buterin (Ethereum Co-founder) – Mechanism Design Experiments in Blockchains (May 2021)


Chapters

00:00:57 Diverse Blockchain Experiments in Economics, Finance, and Governance
00:06:43 Algorithmic Stablecoins: Mechanisms and Innovations
00:11:41 Mechanics of Stablecoins
00:14:12 Delegated Proof-of-Stake Governance Experimentation
00:16:57 Quadratic Funding and Uniswap: Novel Approaches to Funding Public Goods and Decentralized
00:21:41 Understanding Uniswap: A Decentralized Cryptocurrency Exchange
00:25:25 Exploring Token Issuance Models and Various Designs in Proof of Stake Consensus
00:32:28 Blockchain Experiments and Learnings

Abstract

Exploring the Frontier of Blockchain: Innovations, Challenges, and Future Potential

In the rapidly evolving landscape of blockchain technology, a variety of experimental practices and mechanisms are being tested and refined. This in-depth analysis delves into the key areas of experimentation within the blockchain ecosystem, exploring everything from monetary policies and governance designs to funding models for public goods and innovations in decentralized exchanges like Uniswap. The article adopts an inverted pyramid style, commencing with the most significant developments and gradually delving into detailed explorations and case studies.

Groundbreaking Innovations and Experimentations in Blockchain

Blockchains revolutionize the financial and economic landscape, enabling experimentation with diverse mechanisms, including automated logic via smart contracts. Easy payment acceptance and sending in cryptocurrencies simplify applications and designs. Trustless money-holding systems enhance scalability and value handling.

The blockchain space, much like the early internet, is a breeding ground for innovation. Experimentation in diverse monetary policies, currency competition, and varied market designs is at the forefront, driven by the blockchain’s capacity to facilitate new economic models. Particularly noteworthy is Ethereum’s smart contract functionality, which allows applications to interact seamlessly, showcasing the power of composability in blockchain technology. Algorithmic stablecoins, such as Rai, represent a sophisticated approach to addressing cryptocurrency price volatility, demonstrating the potential for decentralized monetary policies.

Additionally, token issuance models in blockchain projects combine aspects of corporations and open source projects. Transparent token issuance is crucial, especially in Asia, to balance rewards for early contributors and prevent plutocracy in the future. Various models exist, including direct premines, token sales, treasuries, and retroactive distribution.

Decentralized Governance and the Evolution of Monetary Systems

The blockchain arena is experimenting with various governance models, including on-chain and off-chain mechanisms. Ethereum’s smart contracts and internal transactions allow for a level of automation and interaction unprecedented in traditional systems. The rise of algorithmic stablecoins like Rai and Dai, with their intricate mechanisms for maintaining price stability, exemplifies the innovative monetary models emerging in this space. However, the failures of Delegated Proof of Stake (DPoS) governance in systems like EOS and Steem highlight the ongoing challenges of ensuring fair and effective governance within decentralized networks.

Complex systems often require governance models for feature agreement and parameter changes. On-chain governance utilizes coded mechanisms to automatically implement decisions. Off-chain governance involves social coordination tools, with users manually implementing rule changes. Voting mechanisms, membership concepts, and scope of governance authority vary across different models.

Non-coin-driven governance models, including people-driven governance and governance with specific participants, are being considered. Anti-civil mechanisms aim to prevent attacks and centralization by limiting the power of large token holders. Proof of Humanity and Proof of Attendance protocols promote one-token-per-person mechanics and participation-based rewards. On-chain auctions are being used for various purposes, such as ticket sales and governance.

Experiments with Delegated Proof-of-Stake Chains and Their Pitfalls

In exploring governance models, blockchains experimented with Delegated Proof-of-Stake (DPoS) chains. These chains allowed for more activist sovereignty and powerful governance than other consensus mechanisms. However, in practice, they encountered challenges. DPoS chains, with their coin voting mechanism, often collapsed into extreme plutocracy. Wealthy individuals and exchanges captured the rewards and governance power, leading to failures in governance systems like EOS and Steem. Solutions are being sought to address these challenges, such as quadratic funding and innovative governance mechanisms. Additionally, the possibility of forking the blockchain and deleting the coins of those responsible for bad decisions is considered, though it remains imperfect.

Funding Public Goods: Quadratic Funding and the Gitcoin Grants Success Story

One of the most notable contributions of the blockchain ecosystem is the introduction of new funding mechanisms for public goods. Quadratic funding, used effectively by platforms like Gitcoin Grants, has shown great promise in supporting projects such as Uniswap, a decentralized exchange. This innovative funding model allocates resources based on broad participation and appeal, addressing the classic tragedy of the commons dilemma. Uniswap itself is a testament to the effectiveness of decentralized models, offering an automated market maker system that has gained popularity for its liquidity and low fees.

Designs for exchanges other than Uniswap, such as descending price auctions and frequent batch auctions, are being explored. Mechanism design in proof-of-stake consensus focuses on rewarding correct participation, penalizing incorrect participation, and avoiding centralization.

The Broader Implications and Future of Blockchain Technology

The blockchain space has brought to light the critical importance of public goods and the need for robust governance mechanisms. The experimentation with algorithmic stablecoins and token sale models has yielded both successes and failures, providing valuable insights into economic realities and the need for fair distribution mechanisms. Moreover, the ongoing developments in blockchain scalability promise to decrease transaction fees significantly, opening up new avenues for application and experimentation.

In conclusion, the blockchain ecosystem, characterized by its continuous experimentation and innovation, presents a dynamic and evolving landscape. From governance models and funding mechanisms to stablecoin designs and decentralized exchanges, the space is redefining the boundaries of technology and economics. The lessons learned from both successes and failures within this ecosystem are shaping a future that holds immense potential for further innovation and development in blockchain technology.

Blockchains facilitate the creation of new institutions based on economic incentives, social motivations, and intrinsic motivations. Proof-of-humanity and similar protocols provide formal structures for participation and governance. Blockchains enable experimentation with different design levels, making it easier to fork and modify systems. However, blockchains also make it easier to break institutions due to anonymity and difficulty in catching attackers. Instead of hunting the wolves (attackers), the focus should be on armoring the sheep (defending systems). This mindset shift could lead to a more peaceful and functional world, with less emphasis on hunting attackers and more on securing systems. Cryptocurrency forces people to adopt this mindset, as attackers are inevitable and economic incentives attract them.


Notes by: MythicNeutron