Jennifer Doudna (UC Berkeley Professor) – CRISPR Workshop, Innovative Genomics Institute (Nov 2017)
Chapters
Abstract
The Revolutionary Impacts and Intricacies of CRISPR-Cas9 Technology
Leading the Charge in Genetic Engineering: Unveiling the Depths of CRISPR-Cas9
CRISPR-Cas9 technology, a groundbreaking tool in genetic engineering, emerged from fundamental understanding of bacteria’s adaptive immune systems, particularly the discovery of repetitive DNA sequences called CRISPRs and associated Cas proteins. This technology’s ability to precisely alter DNA sequences has sparked significant societal, ethical, and scientific discussions. By leveraging the unique properties of CRISPR (Clusters of Regularly Interspaced Short Palindromic Repeats) and CRISPR-associated (Cas) proteins, particularly Cas9, researchers have developed innovative methods for genome editing. However, the discovery of anti-CRISPR proteins, offering a means to modulate CRISPR-Cas9 activity, adds complexity to this evolving narrative. As the potential applications of CRISPR-Cas9 expand, including germline editing and the creation of modified organisms, the necessity for responsible progress and thorough regulatory considerations becomes increasingly evident.
Unraveling the Mechanism of CRISPR-Cas9
Central to CRISPR-Cas9’s functionality is its RNA-guided DNA cutting mechanism. CRISPR RNA (crRNA), derived from the CRISPR array, combines with tracer RNA to guide the Cas9 protein to specific DNA sequences. This precise targeting enables Cas9 to create double-stranded breaks in DNA, which are then repaired by the cell’s natural mechanisms. This process has been harnessed for genome editing, exemplified by targeted changes in organisms like tomatoes and the removal of HIV proviruses in mice.
The Diversity and Classification of CRISPR Systems
CRISPR systems are classified into two main categories: Class I and Class II. Class I systems involve multiple Cas proteins and CRISPR RNAs to form surveillance complexes, while Class II systems, exemplified by Cas9, are simpler, employing a single large protein for function. This simplicity has facilitated Class II systems’ adoption in gene editing technologies.
Cas9: A Key Player in Gene Editing
The Cas9 protein, a pivotal component of Class II CRISPR systems, recognizes and unwinds DNA sequences that match a specific sequence in the guide RNA. This process does not rely on external energy sources, highlighting the protein’s efficiency. Crystallographic studies reveal that Cas9 undergoes significant structural changes upon nucleic acid binding, reorienting itself to facilitate DNA cleavage.
Exploring Conformational Changes and Anti-CRISPR Proteins
Researchers employ techniques like Fluorescence Resonance Energy Transfer (FRET) assays to monitor Cas9’s conformational changes. These studies have unveiled intermediate confirmations in Cas9, dependent on DNA and guide RNA complementarity. Additionally, the discovery of anti-CRISPR proteins, such as the C1 anti-CRISPR, that inhibit Cas9 by blocking its interaction with guide RNA, opens new avenues for controlling this technology’s activity.
The Role of Cas9’s HNH Domain and Variant Proteins
The HNH domain of Cas9 is critical for DNA cleavage, as evidenced by variants lacking this domain being unable to perform DNA cutting. Furthermore, anti-CRISPR proteins interact directly with this domain, inhibiting the conformational change necessary for DNA cutting. This interaction provides insights into the protein-protein associations critical for Cas9’s functionality.
Modulating Cas9 Activity:
Researchers are actively developing techniques to regulate Cas9 enzymes in cells, employing engineered proteins and natural components to enhance safety and accuracy. Anti-CRISPRs are utilized to limit Cas9 activity at off-target sites, improving specificity.
CRISPR Adaptation:
Adaptation involves acquiring new viral sequences into CRISPR arrays. A CRISPR integrase complex, consisting of six protein copies, precisely integrates DNA fragments into the CRISPR array. In E. coli K12, a DNA binding protein contributes to the accuracy and efficiency of the integration process.
Potential Applications:
George Church’s lab has harnessed the integrase as a technology for cell recording, integrating DNA bits into cell populations, similar to natural mechanisms. Unexplored aspects of CRISPR systems hold promise for future applications, leveraging natural mechanisms, including adaptation.
Cas9 Inhibition:
Inhibiting one domain of Cas9 affects cutting of the other DNA strand, indicating a strong coupling between the two domains.
Technological and Societal Implications of CRISPR-Cas9
The rapid adoption of CRISPR-Cas9 in various applications underscores the need for responsible progress and thorough ethical considerations. Germline editing, in particular, has triggered discussions on its implications and the need for regulatory frameworks. The National Academy of Sciences has contributed to these discussions with documents on human genome editing.
Future Directions: Beyond Core Cas9 Activity
Looking forward, the exploration of CRISPR systems extends beyond core Cas9 activity. Researchers are investigating aspects such as cell recording and information storage, and the adaptation process by which bacteria incorporate new viral sequences into CRISPR arrays. The potential of anti-anti-CRISPR proteins and the need to bridge in vitro and in vivo studies also remain critical areas of ongoing research.
In conclusion, CRISPR-Cas9 technology represents a paradigm shift in genetic engineering, offering unparalleled precision and versatility. While its potential for revolutionizing medicine and biology is immense, the accompanying ethical, societal, and scientific challenges necessitate a collaborative, well-regulated approach to harness its full potential responsibly.
Notes by: Hephaestus